I'm looking for a cooling aftershave balm with a nice menthol kick. I've tried Nivea's Cooling Balm but wasn't a big fan. Any suggestions? Thanks for all of the help.
I really like Proraso aftershave balm. It's very nice, but has a mild menthol kick. You may want to try the aftershave milks from The Shave Den. The mentholated versions are great. The best part is that you can buy generous samples (that will last a good month) at a very reasonable cost. My favorites are the iced peppermint and the iced cedarwood.