What's new

CD/Vinyl vs Digital Music Collections

This is a debate I always ponder about, and I thought it would be interesting to see what others think about it.

When it comes to purchasing music, I find myself purchasing physical CD's still. I like collecting music and I like owning the tangible product. It's also very rewarding to take an album to a live show, meet your favorite artist afterwards, and have him/her/them sign your CD. I enjoy leafing through the linear notes, looking at the pictures, and enjoying the other benefits that come with real albums like posters and stickers.

However, the truth is my CD collection really just takes up space. All I do when I purchase a new CD is rip it to my computer, look through the notes, and shelf it. I don't listen to the CD ever again unless I'm driving in my car. Moreover, digital albums are surprisingly cheap on stores like Amazon. Often, you can snag a brand new album for $4.99 vs the minimum $9.99 to buy the CD. It seems much more financially responsible to buy a digital copy of album and then burn it to a CD if I ever want to use it in a CD player rather than buy a physical CD that I rarely use. Not only that, but if I switched to digital I could sell all my CD's, which would reclaim space and some extra money.

Still, in light of this, I still find myself collecting CD's. I try to buy used as much as possible to keep costs down, but I won't let that prevent me from buying albums new.

My friend had an interesting approach to the situation. He told me that he buys all his music digitally except for albums he knows he's going to listen over and over. Classic albums like London Calling by the Clash and Stand! by Sly and the Family Stone. For these significant albums, he buys vinyl - because as most audiophiles say - Vinyl is the best way to go. I thought about this approach, but was unsure if I was really willing to repurchase albums that I already own on vinyl. Also, I don't know if I could decide which albums got the vinyl treatment and would probably end up upgrading everything to vinyl :blink:. Still,it was an interesting take on the situation as opposed to do one or another.

So I'll open the discussion to others. What do you buy? Do you prefer one to another? Would you go purely digital? Or is there a significant reason why you want to stick to CD's and Vinyl? Or do you have an interesting solution?

It seems like every day we are getting closer to digital distribution that I wonder is it even worth fighting.
 
I am too young for vinyl but grew up collecting CDs and have accumulated a vast collection. Last year I purchased an Ipod and really enjoy having my entire music collection available at my fingertips. I have recently begun buying albums from I tunes. It is a great resource for me since I live in a small country town and local music stores range of CDs is very limited.
Having said that, if I really enjoy an album purchased from I tunes I will buy the CD too (usually online).
It is nice to have the cover art, the sleeve notes and a real CD to hold. An album is more than the sum of its parts and it provides a far more complete experience than a digital download.

Pete
 

Luc

"To Wiki or Not To Wiki, That's The Question".
Staff member
I used to have a huge CD collection. Up until I sent the CDs to my mom to be storaged for a few months. First thing I know, they did a garage sale and sold all my stuff (including +500 CDs that I sent over there) for $300.

Not happy!

However, given the choice now, I'm waiting to buy a good quality turn table to buy vinyls. It's a bit of nostagia but also those special records that are out there that never made it to a CD!
 
I have been to many audiophile trade shows and came to a sole conclusion: a $1,000 turntable sounds better than a $10,000 CD player.
 
I have been to many audiophile trade shows and came to a sole conclusion: a $1,000 turntable sounds better than a $10,000 CD player.

Yup.

That said, I am a huge fan of CDs, but not of digital music in general. A nice CD based audiophile system is fantastic, but mp3s in comparison (even high bitrate or lossless formats) still pale in comparison...and none of them can beat analog for sheer presence and musicality.
 
Personally I think the quality of CDs is better than digital. Even if you burn the digital music into a copied cd I can tell the difference.

However as stated above, CDs are expensive, and I don't think the price will be competitive over digital music.

IMHO, with digital music, people are more likely to purchase one or two songs that they like. This to me is just supporting 'one-hit-wonder' type of music, thus the quality of the musician is not all that important.
 
I have been to many audiophile trade shows and came to a sole conclusion: a $1,000 turntable sounds better than a $10,000 CD player.

Oh yes, amen brother! I have a Rotel 1062 and a Pro-ject Expression III - both similarly priced and the table embarrasses the CD player. Most new albums are available on vinyl and most come with a download included - so you get the convenience of having it in digital format and the tangible piece of vinyl with the terrific sleeve and artwork. I hardly ever buy CDs anymore. The turntable is an instrument for playing recorded music - like all instruments it's based on vibration and that's why it sounds real. :thumbup1:
 
I have the same tendency of wanting to have the physical CD and ripping it into FLAC format for playback and archival. The CD is nice to have for backup but as you say not really necessary.

...
My friend had an interesting approach to the situation. He told me that he buys all his music digitally except for albums he knows he's going to listen over and over. Classic albums like London Calling by the Clash and Stand! by Sly and the Family Stone. For these significant albums, he buys vinyl - because as most audiophiles say - Vinyl is the best way to go. I thought about this approach, but was unsure if I was really willing to repurchase albums that I already own on vinyl. Also, I don't know if I could decide which albums got the vinyl treatment and would probably end up upgrading everything to vinyl :blink:. Still,it was an interesting take on the situation as opposed to do one or another.

Jonathan Berger, professor of music at Stanford theorized -
The Sizzling Sound of Music or Young music fans deaf to iPod’s limitations . So maybe your friend is just reflecting different preferences due to the format he originally experienced the music on. Classic vinyl albums versus modern mp3.
 
Another dying breed is the tube amplifier. A tube amp, while being expensive and high maintenance, will beat the living pants off of a solid state sytem for sheer musicality (unless you are playing [c]rap). Female voices sound like they are in the room.
 
Another dying breed is the tube amplifier. A tube amp, while being expensive and high maintenance, will beat the living pants off of a solid state sytem for sheer musicality (unless you are playing [c]rap). Female voices sound like they are in the room.

I've a custom made valve phono stage between my turntable and amplifiers, takes a little while to warm up, but once it gets there it sings. Of course my main amplifiers are solid state but Creek make pretty good ones :)
 
Good question! I buy CDs if its an older recording done at at time when the technology is not as polished as it is now because the sound is way better than a digital one. I buy digital if it's a possible "meh" band or more recent as the sound will be really decent on an ipod and the price alright.

I would rather have vinyl if I can as I just get more excited about leafing through a vinyl bin than looking at a CD display. I like liner notes and having a physical item but I dont have the space anymore but I rarely buy digital unless it's a band I really want and the CD is out of print.
 
Very interesting thread! I have developed a strong CDAD through the years and I'm entirely happy with it :tongue_sm. I spend a lot of time listening to music, mainly classical and sometimes jazz and it's really nice to take a CD, open it, put it into the player and read booklet... And now the cons :thumbdown. Yes, they take some space. But everything take some space, books, even razors. And I like music so why could i bother with it? Some people talks about the price of CDs. All what I can say is if you want, you can find CDs cheaper and buy them without any big heartaches. And yes, vinyl is better. But now I don't have enough money to see the difference. So maybe later :biggrin1:.
 
As a former audiophile, I'd love to say I'd go with the 'quality' of a great tube amp and a good LP, but to be honest I just don't listen to great music to begin with. In addition, even when I am listening to music now, I'm either in the car or doing yard work...so having tons of digital music on an mp3 player just makes more sense to me at this stage of my life.
 
I always think its good to have a physical product when it comes to albums, especially if its a band I'm really into. This is probably a bit weird but I think the artwork of an album somehow relates to the music on the album when I listen to it, can't really explain what I mean! I do have a lot of music only on my hard drive, its just so convenient. I miss that connection of finding an album in a record shop. Also some albums come in cool packaging which I'm a sucker for. Like Shellac's albums, they also include a free CD with the vinyl version, awesome.
 
I was a child of the cassette era, but I think Vinyl sounds the best.

I have over 1000 LPs. I have too many addictions :glare:
 
Another dying breed is the tube amplifier. A tube amp, while being expensive and high maintenance, will beat the living pants off of a solid state sytem for sheer musicality (unless you are playing [c]rap). Female voices sound like they are in the room.

Not dying at all it's still very popular-relatively. However the sound is dependent on the tubes and good tubes just aren't being made anymore and vintage ones are astronomical in price.

As far as CDs and Vinyl go if you have a really good CD player the sound with vinyl is about the same, not quite but very very close. The kicker is to get the max out of vinyl in addition to having to have pristine records you need to invest alot in equipment. When I had a 1 grand turntable system the CDs sounded way better. Pure digital computer type stuff is for convenience it ain't audiophile grade.
 
for me it's having a tangible product in my hands versus having an intagible digital file. I like the collector side of music, especially if it's something that's considered limited edition. to me mp3's cheapen the art of music and has turned music into a throwaway item. I have over 3000 cd's and records but have scaled my purchases back simply because I have more important things to spend my money on at the moment. besides, I will always enjoy the hunt of record shopping and finding that long lost gem
 
for me it's having a tangible product in my hands versus having an intagible digital file. I like the collector side of music, especially if it's something that's considered limited edition. to me mp3's cheapen the art of music and has turned music into a throwaway item. I have over 3000 cd's and records but have scaled my purchases back simply because I have more important things to spend my money on at the moment. besides, I will always enjoy the hunt of record shopping and finding that long lost gem

Yup. I agree, totally.
 
I used to have a huge CD collection. Up until I sent the CDs to my mom to be storaged for a few months. First thing I know, they did a garage sale and sold all my stuff (including +500 CDs that I sent over there) for $300.

Not happy!

However, given the choice now, I'm waiting to buy a good quality turn table to buy vinyls. It's a bit of nostagia but also those special records that are out there that never made it to a CD!

Everything for $300? Without telling you? Not cool.
 
I am too young for vinyl but grew up collecting CDs and have accumulated a vast collection. Last year I purchased an Ipod and really enjoy having my entire music collection available at my fingertips. I have recently begun buying albums from I tunes. It is a great resource for me since I live in a small country town and local music stores range of CDs is very limited.
Having said that, if I really enjoy an album purchased from I tunes I will buy the CD too (usually online).
It is nice to have the cover art, the sleeve notes and a real CD to hold. An album is more than the sum of its parts and it provides a far more complete experience than a digital download.

Pete

How old? I'm 24 and personally prefer Vinyl to everything else..... My parents gave me there collections, and I've added a few to it :D

Tom
 
Top Bottom