any Japanese aftershave WITHOUT menthol/Castor Oil?

[smalltank]

just curious if anyone knows of any Japanese aftershaves WITHOUT plants/oils/extracts..Castor Oil and Menthol seem like they are in many AS's

ST

 

[Luc]

Mandom doesn't have menthol but I'm not sure about castor oil.

 

[mblakele]

Mandom doesn't have menthol but I'm not sure about castor oil.

Luc, we have the ingredients on the wiki: Mandom_Aftershave_Lotion

Ethanol, Water, DPG, PEG-8, Diisopropyl adipate, PEG-50 Hydrogenated castor oil, Oleth-8 Sodium phosphate, Oxybenzone-2, EDTA-2 Sodium, Fragrance, Yellow 203, Red 401.

I do not see menthol, but I see castor oil. It seems to be hydrogenated, if that makes any difference?

The Mandom_Lucido_Aftershave has menthol, but no castor oil.

 

[smalltank]

Well...the castor oil..from the plant...unless it says castor "acid"...oils are said to be the highest potency of the ingredient...below that is acid....which is usually fine.

 

[Luc]

I remembered that Mandom did not have any menthol when I used it but I forgot to check the ingredient list in wiki, thanks Mike. All the other ones (Japanese Aftershaves) that I tried all had menthol in them (MG5, Bravas, Lordos). The only other exception (just thought about it) was the Kanebo 9 o'clock (no menthol) - http://wiki.badgerandblade.com/Kanebo_Nine_OClock_Aftershave

Again, not sure about the castor oil as the ingredient list was in Japanese when I read it. It had good aquatic scent!