If you are a fan of bay rum A/S and also like to use witch hazel before applying your A/S check out Humphrey's Alcoholado Maravilla witch hazel. It has a very per complimenting scent to bat rum.
I used a generic witch hazel today for the first time. I can see myself using it in lieu of aftershave when I don't want scented products. (It evaporates so fast afterwards)