I have to go with Penhaligon's Lime on the high end and TOBS Victorian Lime on the lower end of the price spectrum.
Anglia Perfumery Imperial Lime - nice sharp long lasting.
Anglia Perfumery Spiced Limes.
I really liked the C&E West Indian Lime, soap was crap though, the balm is nice. RazoRock's Essential Oil of Lime is too candy'ish for my liking.
+1.Royall Lyme
I'm a big fan of Stirling Margaritas in the Arctic, although you'll only find it as a WH or AS splash.
Stephans Island Lime! Get some, you'll love it.
CHEERS!
--T
C&E's new limes soap is excellent as is the balm. I wish they would do an aftershave lotion, as where I live is so hot and humid.
My vote is for Trumper's limes for the fragrance overall.