Another vote for MWF or Prep.
Tabula Rasa unscented, though there is controversy whether it's a soap or a cream.
I suspect your reaction was due to the benzaldehyde from the sweet almond fragrance; there is nothing else in there which could cause it. As such I'm very hesitant to recommend Cella, which too contains almond fragrance, but a lot less. However if you still have signs of the reaction then I'd suggest to not even take the gamble. Most other almond-fragranced soaps and creams are out for you too, for example Col. Conk Almond, or TOBS Almond cream, but also almost all other soft Italian soaps too.Last Saturday I had the worst shave ever because an allergic reaction to P.160 and still I have the signs of it. Instead of throw it away id like to trade it, along some other Italian stuff like Valobra and Figaro, but which one?
tabula rasa unscented, though there is controversy whether it's a soap or a cream.
Are you in the US? If so PM your address and I'll send you a puck of VDH for sensitive skin. I personally VDH is way better than Williams and its available in US drugstores.