Love this stuff and what I was going to say to try oLucky Tiger Aftershave and Face Tonic would be my suggestion.
I always have a bottle on hand. It's my son's go-to post shave product.
ld spice and this are my main two and prefer the no alcohol of the Lucky
I do have some thayers but not sure about the scent forgot what it is ? But mine also has the alcohol in it so its more a thayers aftershave hazel mix I guess ? Not sure which one that is but no sticky for me either