Need advice on AS to pair with this soap.

[Scumpy]

My Oleo Soapworks order came in yesterday and I must say I really like the canard soaps. I ordered Pucker and Seibo and I like both scents. I have Maggards Limes and Bergamot that I'll use with the Pucker, I'm looking for suggestions for the Seibo though. Oleo offers AS splash and balm but the splash is alcohol, water and fragrance so not what I'm looking for. Balms are generally too heavy and I don't enjoy them either. I'm looking for an aftershave that is in the middle and leaves my face soft and elastic with no greasy layer after. The description of the scent from the vendor site is "The scent of rich cocoa blended with sweet milk and real cocoa powder". I would say that is pretty spot on, its a very pleasant cocoa scent. I've looked at the Mickey Lee Drunken Goat or maybe PAA Chocolate Bourbon. Any advice you may offer will be welcome.