Varen
Sheep
Scots Pine Sheep
Glastonbury
Sheep again
I have pucks of both Varen and Sheep, and love both of em, though my wife hates the Varen scent.
I like the mutton tallow base so much (and have heard others say the mutton tallow is their best base), so I'm content to not explore their other bases.
Alright. I could NOT pick out 5! I picked out 14!
Executive Man
Stirling Gentleman
Mountain Man
Baker Street
Sharp Dressed Man
Island Man
Boat Drinks
Iced Pineapple
Haverford
Almond Creame
Vanilla Sandalwood
Pharaoh's Dreamsicle
Orange Chill
Barbershop
Man! These are all sooooooo good! Thank you everyone for your suggestions!