Zach, if you are leaving that much water in the brush, then 5-10 swirls is not nearly enough. Hit that soap for a good minute until the froth is going berserk, and then hit the bowl. Also, I think the C-M soap is hard to lather. you might want to try something else. The Taylors creams you mention are great. I would get the Rose and forgo the Eton college.
If you continue to have issues, I would be happy to take some pictures to help you out.
If you continue to have issues, I would be happy to take some pictures to help you out.