Ron R
I survived a lathey foreman
This is useful. Thanks!
This is a tough one to answer because there are so many variables. I do have several AC razors, though, and can offer up my impressions (not in any particular order). Hopefully you’ll find something beneficial in them. I will add that I am not a head shaver, so I can’t speak to that at all. I have a very coarse beard that grows fast and I shave daily.
1. Vector. This is the king of the AC hill as far as I’m concerned. It’s the most versatile as it will fit into areas none of the others can. Yes, the Romulus is similarly sized, but the geometry and blade exposure of the Vector allows it to shave efficiently at a wider range of angles. You can fine tune the aggression with blade selection dramatically. With mild guarded blades it is quite tame, with Super Pros it’s as aggressive as I’m interested in. Standard sized unguarded options have been the best for me so far. It’s not perfect, though. It’s not the smoothest ac razor I own. I find it plenty comfortable, but if you do not enjoy blade feel it’s probably not for you. As I mentioned, it’s quite “adjustable” via blade choice, but if you’re looking for a very mild ac razor the Vector cannot do that as well as others. Also there is the cost, of course. Even second hand it will run more than most of the others.
2. Razorock Hawk v3. This is a fantastic option as well. It’s not as maneuverable as the Vector, but it’s certainly not clumsy either. I only have the standard plate and most AC fans seem to find it too mild. I like it, though. With a standard sized blade it offers a very smooth, comfortable shave for me. Pretty much a guaranteed comfortable dfs. You can obviously increase the aggression by using Super Pro blades and I find this works very well. If that’s not to your liking there are two more plates that will increase aggression/efficiency. The build quality is excellent with many handle options (I recommend the titanium halo).
3. Romulus. Some folks in the SE forums pretty aggressively oppose the existence of the Romulus due to its similar appearance to the Vector. I’m not one of them as I own both and recognize that they are very different razors, but it’s something to be aware of. Obviously Yaqi uses the squared off threaded post like the Vector, but that’s pretty much where the similarities end from a user experience. The Vector is designed to be medium to medium aggressive with a standard blade. From there you can tone it down or amp it up with blade choice. The same logic applies to the Romulus, but it is significantly milder in its base configuration. Using guarded blades in it results in a very mild shave that is comparable to a R89/DE89. The Romulus with a Super Pro might be similar to the Vector with a standard blade. The mild nature and smaller blade exposure limit the effective range of shaving angles and regardless of head size I do not find it as maneuverable as the Vector. Build quality is very good, especially if you like the stock handle. I prefer to use mine with the Razorock titanium halo or vintage thin handles.
4. Excalibur. I don’t have a lot to say about this one as I almost never use it. I bought it for travel purposes and have only used it a couple times really. It was fine, but I wouldn’t recommend it over any of these. I will point out that the head is not the same as the Romulus. The blade geometry is quite different and they do not shave the same. I find the Romulus smoother, more maneuverable and more efficient.
5. Razorock Hawk v2. This one is pretty good, but hard to recommend with the existence of the v3 and Romulus. It’s a good bargain and a good shaver, but the overall experience is not as good as the others. I find the v2 both less efficient and less smooth. Probably comparable to the Romulus in aggression, but not as comfortable. Certainly not as smooth or efficient as the v3.
Hopefully there’s something useful to you in all that rambling. I will sum it up by saying if I could have only one ac razor it would be the Vector. If I could have two it would be the Vector and Hawk v3. The truth is the AC format and its array of blade options could make any one of these razors work for most people.
Very well written review IMO, I find it accurate and full of your personal experiences that should help folks decide what they might like to use and buy.
I have the Yaqi Romulus and Yaqi Excalibur razors and they work well for my shaving needs. Your comments are accurate on these two razors IMO. I have used the Yaqi Excalibur for over 2 years(with over 100 uses) because of my large razor rotation. The Excalibur is affordable and a great entry level 50mm blade type or AC type razor and the Romulus is affordable also when bought on sale IMO.
The Romulus is very accurately machined and finish QC is excellent & is on the mild side and it also has positive blade exposure with a Standard Gillette blade I have tested. Use a Feather super pro and it bumps it up notch for blade feel or a blade shim will increase blade exposure if a person wants to experiment a little for more blade feel (some folks like blade feel like myself).
All said very happy with the these razors so far.