Your Top 5 Aftershaves??

[JohnnyVader]

1. PAA John Frum
2. A&E Warrior of the Howling Fjord (how great is that name?)
3. Clubman
4. B&M Le Grand Chypre
5. A tie between a bunch of PAA‘s

All but that number 1 can change from time to time and how I’m feeling.

 

[Nofx_Phan]

There really are so many fine aftershaves.

Splashes: TOBS Sandalwood, Ach Brito Lavanda, Musgo Real Classic, Floid Vigoroso, Tabac..

Balms: Tabac, Speick, Stray Whisker

 

[Jakebullet]

I’ve only got a few
Proraso green, fresh and does the job.
Fine snakebite (would be number one but it’s so crazy).
Brut, leaves a great post shave feel.
Floid Vigoroso, old style scent and does a great job only need a drop.
Speick, lovely and fresh and soothing.
I like a fleeting scent or no scent at all, and all these are very fleeting on me except for the Floid and the brut which last an hour or two.

 

[Tanmay Jha]

Osage Rub
Aqua Velva
Skin Bracer
Old Spice
Gillette arctic ice

 

[Shaving like a boss]

Skin Bracer Cool Spice
Skin Bracer Original
Clubman Whiskey Woods
Gillette SunUp
Gabels Bay Rum

 

[ask4Edge]

No.88
Opaline
Camaldoli
Windsor (drh)
Proraso (green)

 

[merovirginian]

I don't have an extensive selection, maybe 12 total. I always add some menthol as well. But, the ones that stand out and are not dupes of popular colognes:
(1) ETHOS Mysore Santal
(2) Murphy and McNeil Cliffs of Moher
(3) J Peterman 1903
(4) PannaCrema Nuavia Blu
(*) either uncensored or cologne dupes

 

[Ganko]

Floid
Furbo blue
Vitos tabac