What's new

Your Top 3 Cigars

Pardon Anniversary 1964: My favorite high end for the $$
Oliva V: To me the best overall cigar for $$
Oliva Gilberto Reserva Blanc: My favorite every day medium cigar for the $$
 

Isaac

B&B Tease-in-Residence
H Upmann Mag 46
H Upmann Sir Winnie
Vegas Robaina Famosos

Not far behind

Fonseca #1
 

Hirsute

Used to have fun with Commander Yellow Pantyhose
H Upmann vintage Cameroon belicoso
Montecristo 2
Bolivar Cofradia 654


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Padron 1964 best overall
Ashton VSG
Montecristo white series

Among Many others but usually this is what I reach for most of the time.
Arturo Fuentes is pretty good too as well as Davidoff but I don’t smoke them as often.





Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Columbo

Mr. Codgers Neighborhood
1. Padron '64 Imperial
2. (see number 1)
3. Whatever my friend Pat picks out of the cabinet after the third bourbon and water.
 
Padron 1964 best overall
Ashton VSG
Montecristo white series

Among Many others but usually this is what I reach for most of the time.
Arturo Fuentes is pretty good too as well as Davidoff but I don’t smoke them as often.





Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
VSG was the first cigar that I fell in love with and would probably be my fourth on this list. It would probably be in my top 3 if the damn thing would ever go on sale.
 

seabee1999

On the lookout for new chicks
I don’t smoke cigars as often as I had in the past; however, the ones I would smoke were always ones I’d look for and forward to smoking. My number one favorite still of all time is a Montecristo #2 followed closely by a Cohiba Robusto. Don’t necessarily need a third one if I have access to the above two.
 
You know, this is an impossible question for me, as a cigar must fit your mood, the time of day, and the situation. Thus - I shall break the rules and share multiple “top three lists”

Top 3 Cigars to Pair with a Cup of Coffee in the AM
1. Villiger Cuellar Kreme Toro
2. Quai D’Orsay 50
3. Atabey Hechizos

Top Three Evening Cigars to pair with Scotch/Bourbon/Rum neat
1. Montecristo No 2 (Cuban)
2. Padron Serie 1926 80 Year Maduro
3. Sin Compromiso No 2

Top Three Relax and Chill Sticks
1. Davidoff Nicaragua Toro (standard, not box pressed version)
2. Plasencia Alma Fuerte Generacion V Salomon
3. LFD Andalusian Bull

Top Three Unique Smokes
1. Plasencia Alma Del Fuego Flama
2. Davidoff Escurio Gran Perfecto
3. Platinum Nova Perfecto

Top Three Interesting Looking/Tasting sticks to Hand to a Guest
1. Sinistro Last Cowboy Maduro Scala LE
2. Arturo Fuente Between the Lines
3. LFD TCFKA “M” Collector’s Edition

Top Three Special Celebration Sticks
1. Davidoff Royal Release Robusto
2. Arturo Fuente Opus X 20th Anniversary Power of the Dream
3. Cohiba Behike 54

My honorable mentions were too vast to mention.
 

never-stop-learning

Demoted To Moderator
Staff member
In no particular order:

El Original Corona (Claro) (Island Smoke Shop, Key Largo, FL)
R&J Churchill (Havana)
Bolivar Petite Corona & Belicoso Fino (Havana)
 
Cuban:
1. Cohina Behike 56
2. Hoyo de Monterrey Double Corona
3. Partagas Serie P No. 2

NonCuban:

1. Rocky Patel
2. Padron
3. Hmmmmmmmm My Father/Brickhouse/Arturo Fuente

the Non Cuban.....there's to many to list
 
Cuban:
1. Cohina Behike 56
2. Hoyo de Monterrey Double Corona
3. Partagas Serie P No. 2

NonCuban:

1. Rocky Patel
2. Padron
3. Hmmmmmmmm My Father/Brickhouse/Arturo Fuente

the Non Cuban.....there's to many to list

I’ve never had a Rocky Patel I didn’t think was garbage. Make me eat my shoe - what vitola should I try to change my mind?
 
Top Bottom