Your top 3 aftershaves

[csice]

What are your top three aftershaves in order? You can list more or less, I was just hoping to get an idea of what is popular so as to help give me some direction in my search.

 

[August West]

Krampert's Finest Frostbite/Osage Rub respectively
Old Spice Classic
Speick

EDIT: Check with me in a month. The list will probably change.

 

[jazzguy]

Harris Windsor (I like the milk but the splash is excellent as well)
Speick (best performing splash I've used)
AOS Ocean Kelp

 

[Chrisarelli]

wow there is gonna be a ton of different answers for this one. I'm interested to see what other gentlemen prefer. Out of all the AS's Ive tried so far my top are:

Yardley Black Label or English Lavender
Floid Blue
Speick

Very close to being in the top 3 but still amazing
Myrsol F/extra
Proraso green
Alt-Innsbruck

I'm waiting on a bottle of the swiss pitralon to arrive in the mail and I'm told its incredible so we'll see! Happy shaving

 

[Mick]

Hummm that one is hard...

Clubman
Master Topaz
Tabac

I enjoy all that I have

 

[SIG9]

Floid Blue
Speick
Proraso Green

Captains is nice, but I'm not a big bay rum guy.

 

[BrookR1]

iColoniali emulsion

Can't think of any others because I'm enjoying this one so much.

 

[babydials]

WM Neuman 1911
Seagrape Tea Tree Lavender (which smells like neither because of the whisky base and the patchouli)
Musco Real Classic.

 

[dushea]

Speick
DRH Arlington
Musgo

Close behind: Shulton OS, Proraso

 

[Polerouter]

Proraso green
MG5
Brut

 

[Multics]

Speick Men
Floris No. 89
Truefitt&Hill West Indian Limes

 

[Catalin]

Myrsol Agua Balsamica
La Toja Splash
Musgo Real

 

[Face Bannon]

Skin Bracer
Clubman

 

[Techichi]

Skin Bracer
Clubman Vanilla
Proraso Green

Just got Speick balm and I love the smell. Can't wait to try the splash. It could easily jump up in the top three if it's as good as I hope.

 

[Test4echo]

Floid Genuine
Clubman
Floid Blue

 

[takeshi]

I was just hoping to get an idea of what is popular so as to help give me some direction in my search.

I'd recommend starting with your preferences for scent.

In any case:
DRH Sandalwood

 

[NSmalls]

1.) Floïd Vigoroso
2.) A tie between Tabac and Skin Bracer

 

[the_edski]

In no particular order:

Captains Choice (all of them, but if pressed, the Lime is my favorite)
Skin Bracer
AV Ice Blue

 

[cryhavoc]

Aqua Velva
Pinaud Clubman
Speick

 

[Lakebound]

Myrsol Emulsion
Myrsol Blue
Myrsol Formula F./Extra

Frank