Your Top 10 Aftershaves

[Distorted Vision]

I am currently looking to expand my aftershave collection. I'm interested in your top 10 aftershaves.

 

[BigJ]

Here is my list (in no particular order):
1. Pinaud clubman
2. OS classic
3. Fine American blend
4. Fine L'Orange Noir
5. Speick
6. Floid vigoroso
7. Proraso green
8. Stirling Baker St.
9. Stirling sharp dressed man
10. Pinaud VSOR

 

[AlphaFrank75]

All of my aftershaves are in the top 10 so I'll just list 10 off the top of my head

• Cella
• Proraso Red
• Floid Black
• Clubman Classic
• Clubman VIBR
• Speick
• Floid Blue
• Floid Vigoroso
• Fine American Barber
• Fine L'Orange Noir

 

[OkieStubble]

I possess over 250 aftershaves, so specific brands not withstanding.


1. Woody
2. Smokey
3. Bay Rum
4. Spicy
5. Mossy
6. Citrusy
7. Floral
8. Musk
9. Vetiver
10. Fresh

 

[cryhavoc]

Here is my list (in no particular order):

1. Pinaud Clubman
2. Aqua Velva
3. Old Spice
4. Aqua Velva Musk
5. Speick
6. Pinaud Clubman Citrus Musk
7. Pinaud Clubman VIBR
8. Pinaud Clubman Special Reserve
9. Skin Bracer
10. Fine Fresh Vetiver

 

[discerningbev]

In no order:

1. Floid Vigoroso
2. Stirling Barbershop
3. Stirling Sandalwood
4. Fine Lavender Pour Homme
5. Fine American Blend
6. SMN Tobacco Toscano
7. Pinaud Clubman
8. Barrister and Mann Reserve Cool
9. Proraso Green
10. Barrister and Mann Fougere Gothique

 

[Villalobos]

In order
Avon Leather
Avon Spicy
Skin Bracer
Aqua Velva Ice Blue
Pinuad Clubman
Brut
Avon Oland
Avon Windjammer
Avon Tai Winds
Avon Deep Woods

 

[discerningbev]

I forgot to add Pen’s Blenheim Bouquet which definitely is one of my favorites!

 

[RobW]

The top 3-ish spots change all the time, but a general grouping might look like..

Captain's Choice Sandalwood
Speick
Myrsol F/Extra
Fine American Blend
Captain's Choice Cat o' 9 Tails
Myrsol Agua Balsamica
Clubman VIBR
Mennen Skin Bracer
Myrsol Blue
Pitralon Classic

 

[md1234]

My top ten would be in no particular order:

Barrister and Mann Cool Reserve
Aqua Velva Ice Blue
Myrsol blue
Proraso green
RR Santa Maria del fiore
Pinaud special reserve
Floid vigoroso
Ogallala Bay Rum and Sandalwood
Crown aftershave tonic
Pinaud vanilla

 

[adamchur]

I like them all, so I've listed them alphabetically
I know some of them are technically colognes, but I use cologne the in the same way as I use aftershave

The Top 10
Brut Original (France)
Floïd Vigaroso (Spain)
Jovan Musk (USA)
Old Spice Fresh Lime (India)
Old Spice Original (India)
Pinaud Clubman (USA)
Pino Silvestre (Italy)
Tabac Original (Germany)
Varon Dandy (Spain)
Williams Expert Aqua Velva (Spain)

The Also Rans
Agua Brava Puig (Spain)
comotú aventura (Spain)
Honeybee Gardens Bay Rum (USA)
Old Spice Musk (India)
Русский лес (Russian Forest)
Шипр (Shipr)
тройной (Troynoy)
Suavecito Bay Rum (USA)

 

[ask4Edge]

D. R. Harris (Sandalwood, Arlington, Windsor)
T&H Spanish Leather
Floid Vigoroso (Spain)
Acqua di Parma Colonia
Blenheim Bouquet
Alt-Innsbruck
Tabac Original
S. M. Novella (Patchouli, Lavender)
Czech & Speake Neroli
TOBS Sandalwood

 

[Pepin]

Here are my top ten by company:

1. Pinaud Clubman - Original
2. Pinaud Clubman - Special Reserve
3. Pinaud Clubman - Lilac Vegetal
4. Geo F. Trumper - Spanish leather
5. Tabac
6. Taylor of Old Bond Street - Eton College
7. Taylor of Old Bond Street - Victorian Lime
8. Myrsol - F/Extra
9. Alt Innsbruck
10. Miraculum (Brutal) - Classic

 

[Mullen88]

After 1&2 no particular order.

1) Tallow + Steel Boreal (desert island aftershave)
2) Tallow + Steel Maya
3) Storybook Soapworks Coffee Spoons
4) Dr. Jon’s Flowers In The Dark (all time favourite scent)
5) Midnight & Two Citrus Island
6) Midnight & Two Provence
7) Chatillon Lux Rose Santal
8) Chatillon Lux Champs de Lavande
9) The Holy Black The Tell-Tale Heart
10) PAA The Beach

This list would contain some excellent scents by some other superb artisans but said products give me a bad reaction hence their exclusion.

 

[mmaggi]

Pinaud Clubman
Pinaud VIBR
OS Vintage
Mennen Skin Bracer
Floid Suave
Proraso Green
Pinaud Citrus Musk
Pinaud Lime Sec
OS Musk (India)
Tabac

 

[mpontiff]

Chatillon Lux
Black Ship Grooming
Dr. Jon's
Chiseled Face
Declaration Grooming
Mickey Lee Soapworks
Dapper Dragon Scale Polish
Barrister Reserve

Most of these have ingredients that leave my skin feeling very soft and supple. A few have great longevity and I can smell them up to 8 hours later.

 

[Andreassti1]

Floid Genuine
Floid Vigoroso
Floid Suave
Floid Blue
Stirling Gentleman
Stirling Ozark Mountain
Dr Harris Marlborogh
Fine Green Vetiver
RR Santa Mariea del Fiore
RR Zi Peppino

 

[Gdawgs]

Today, something like this. Might be different tomorrow. As you can see, I'm a big fan of the artisans out there.

Mickey Lee - Grand Havana
Mickey Lee - The Kraken
Stirling - Sandpiper
Stirling - Mountain Man
PAA - Cavendish
Chiseled Face - Ghost Town Barber
Chiseled Face - Sherlock
Fine - American Blend
L&L - Cuir et Epices
Henri et Victoria - Duc de Santal

 

[jdp93]

Floid Blue
Floid Vigaroso
Fine Platinum/American Blend
Speick
CG Ghost Town Barber
B&M Cool
B&M Leviathan
L&L Darkfall
Wholly Kaw Fougere Bouquet/Chypre Rose Concerto
Tallow & Steel Himalaya/Maya

 

[Kreator82]

These are my top 10 out of what I have used so far, since I haven't tried everything.

1. Irisch Moos
2. Stetson CM
3. Cella
4. Proraso Red
5. Pinaud Special Reserve
6. Pinaud Bay Rum
7. AV Ice Blue
8. Pinaud Clubman
9. Brut
10. (Old) Old Spice

This list may change when I get the chance to try some Fine, Stirling, TOBS etc. This is just my current list. The Moos is king right now.