Experiment with the following ingredients in different proportions:
witchhazel
aloe vera gel
glycerin
Essential oils
Right now I'm using a concoction that is about 60% witchhazel, 30% aloe vera gel, 10% glycerin, and contains a few drops of peppermint EO. It smells and feels great.
Hmm. Not too much. Definitely must try the Osage Rub. Been hearing too much about it and I like menthol. Also the SCS Blue Line. I wanna try some of that. Mitchell's Wool Fat, a tube of Musgo, all in due time. Eventually a straight, but that's a long time coming.