I was looking through the coldest aftershave thread and wondered, what is your favorite menthol aftershave? It seems people brought up Osage Rub, Cryogen, Vigoroso, and Proraso green very often. Whether “coldest” is your favorite point or scent+menthol or something else, what’s your favorite menthol AS?
Your favorite menthol aftershave
- Thread starter Dominic
- Start date
This is my favorite. Hey Joe Acid Melon. It has a sweet, melon smell, and a great load of menthol that makes it very refreshing, almost freezing.
Myrsol Formula K and Myrsol Limon are my go-to in very hot days
NEW Original1932
Floid
The Genuine
for the hottest days of Summer: Barbasol Brisk
for other times: Floid Vigoroso
for other times: Floid Vigoroso
Only got proraso green which still is a very nice splash and just ordered the new genuine floid let's see if it lives up to its expectation
Fine Snake Bite!
Floïd
Proraso
Oxford & Cambridge (peppermint)
Proraso
Oxford & Cambridge (peppermint)
Mix Osage Rub with Dickinson's witch hazel toner and a bit of Pereja Turkish limon kolonya. Add a few drops of tea tree oil.
Chiseled Face Ghost Town Barber -- I got it to match the soap without knowing it had menthol; pleasantly surprised. Regular Aqua Velva is also nice.
Another vote (make that votes) for Proraso green in the summer! Then Floid vigoroso in the winter! 
Fine Fresh Vetiver + a little 444
Floid
Aqua Velva
Skin Bracer
Plentiful and pleasing.
Aqua Velva
Skin Bracer
Plentiful and pleasing.
Floid
Osage Rub
Osage Rub
While probably not the "coldest" ASB out there, I've found much happiness with Duke Cannon.
.....
.....
