You are forced to thin your soap herd to 3...which ones?

[captain_hx]

MWF
D.R. Harris
C&S

 

[Heron]

Crabtree & Evelyn Nomad,
Mike's Lemongrass & Eucalyptus, and

Updating my list three years later:

Soap Commander
i Coloniali mango oil
C&E Nomad

 

[OregonGunDog]

B&M Seville
Tabac
Saponificio Varesino Felce Aromatica

 

[BigJ]

Difficult, but for me: Haslinger's schafmilch, Haslinger's sage and Haslinger's sandalwood (as this is my year with Haslinger's)!

 

[Bill Christman]

Can't do it. From last count, I own roughly 9 soaps. Still too many to try and I really enjoy the one's I have.

 

[Cigar Guy]

Haslinger's Schafmilch
MWF
AOS Tallow

 

[Pepin]

Tabac
Geo F. Trumper Eucris
Truefitt & Hill Sandalwood

 

[Clausewitz]

If the man is forcing you to pick only threee shave soaps. Your only response should be a revolt against the Soap Tyranny

 

[Clausewitz]

But since we're playing this game

MWF
Saponificio Varesino
Lea Classic Cream (gotta have a menthol in there for the summer)

 

[SpeedyPC]

IF I had to choose only 3 soap for life this would be.

Mitchell's Wool Fat
Haslinger Schafmilch Sheep Milk & Lanolin (very similar to MWF)
LEA Classic Shaving Soap

 

[SirChangalot]

Haslinger
SV
Cella or Speick, haven't decided yet

 

[Daiku]

Soap Commander
Stirling
Proraso

 

[RT Smoothie]

Stirling Glacial Wintergreen
Stirling Glacial Lemon Chill
Stirling Glacial Obsidian

 

[UserNameTaken]

I could and will likely thin it to just two pretty easily

Sudsy Soapery and Midnight & Two

 

[GKR1]

Panacrema
SV
MdC

 

[prec1se]

Mike's coconut
B&M Seville
La Toja stick

 

[Steve56]

Three, no. There are tons of top quality soaps, asking which three will get you a list of 100 from 33-1/3 people.

Because good soaps are common, I prefer to sort out my selection by scent, not quality, though I demand a high quality soap.

A good fougere - Martin de Candre
A good Lavender, Castle Forbes or Czech and Speake.
A good lime, Castle Forbes or Maggard's Limes and Bergamot, old harder version.
A good rose, Vintage Klar, LpL Rose de Pushkar (a favorite scent), T&F rose, Simpsons Vanilla Rose (can't smell the vanilla) ...
A good almond, Boellis, ABC soft or hard
A spice/leather, I Cloniali mango, discontinued
A 'wild card', whatever I'm in the mood for.

Cheers, Steve

 

[JSuiters]

I'm kinda stuck because I only keep two anyway. One menthol and one regular.

 

[brucered]

If push came to shove and I could only pick one.....Haslinger.

To be honest, I don't need three. Right now I only have three, Haslinger, CiT and IM.

Once those other two are gone, I'm guessing I would gladly replace them with C&S and something else.

 

[yaman]

MdC
MWF
Lea Stick