Got mine today! Not going to shave until tomorrow though.
You and I are in the exact same camp. I think we were shipped the samples sans menthol to see if we would merely parrot others, or if we have a mind of our own.My second use of this AS today. The positive is the feeling it leaves your face with. I could use this instead of WH. An excellent face toner. The only negative (but not for me) is the faint scent. I still don't feel the menthol hit.