Went and picked up my first pucks of Williams tonight. Until this point, I have only experimented with soft soaps like Proraso or creams. Ive also always lathered in a bowl but my wife bought me a shave mug to use, hence why I bought the Williams. I tried to lather it in a bowl after loading with results less that what Im used to with soft soaps. I then tried again with a face lather and got a great result with a good lather and slickness. Does anyone else out there get a better result when face lathering off a puck?