Wholly Kaw shave soap questions

[Ramsay]

A couple of questions about WK soaps:
1. With the scented soaps, do the tallow and vegan versions smell the same, or does the tallow, donkey milk version have any different or gamey scent?
2. I realize this is subjective, but generally speaking, do the tallow/donkey milk and vegan versions perform about the same?
Thanks

 

[Cezar]

Will be watching this thread. I’m interested to try a soap from them. Please share your experience and scent recommendations as well

 

[Ringer]

Many will say that the gap between tallow and vegan soaps have closed dramatically throughout the years. My SV soap (vegan) is a great performer and wouldn't know it wasn't tallow-based. I haven't used the vegan base from WK, so can't say how much different it is from their tallow base. From a scent perspective, I don't think that you'd find that to a discernable difference from vegan to tallow. I personally enjoy Fougere Boquet. Reminds me of Brut a lot if that's your thing.

 

[BanjoCowboyMartaTobes]

I have been wanting to try out some WK soaps. I do not see samples on their site as being offered (Maggards has a small selection) and not having a concise listing of scents drives me bonkers. Almost as bonkers as these stories folks write about the provenance of a soap’s name lol. I’ll end with why can’t these kids use a belt and where are my glasses?

Rant done, happy shave sessions!