Which pumpkin spice soap do you recommend?

[lak611]

I'm looking for a pumpkin spice soap for the season. I know there are different brands available, but I've never tried any pumpkin spice soaps.

Does anyone have suggestions? If there happens to be a pumpkin spice soap that smells great, lathers great, and also contains tallow, that is a plus. However, I'm not partial to tallow. The best smelling and performing soap is what I'm after.

Thanks in advance!

 

[sarimento1]

 

[ylekot]

If the above is real I think it would be very hard to beat on all counts!

 

[Vraad]

top notch lather and post shave feel from the SW, I recently added some spare cocoa butter to it, so now it smells of chocolate pumpkin, very holloweeny.

 

[Kyle89]

Stirling Pumpkin Spice freaking rules haha. I've been using it a ton lately.

Granted, can't speak for the current formula which has more cinnamon (my tub is a few years old), but I'd imagine it being pretty great too.

 

[CCS]

Please take no offense but that looks absolutely disgusting. Then again, I prefer more traditional scents and something that doesn't look like the results of a poor diet.

 

[CLaman]

Please take no offense but that looks absolutely disgusting. Then again, I prefer more traditional scents and something that doesn't look like the results of a poor diet.

While I can't speak for Stirling, I can speak to soap making. It's likely that it's hot process batching, which is a soap product that is fully saponified before being placed in its mold, or container. The consistency of a hot processed soap is that of vaseline before it cures, making it difficult to get into the container without it looking somewhat messy.

Just thought you'd be intrested.

 

[GR5233]

Stirling Pumpkin Spice freaking rules haha. I've been using it a ton lately.

Granted, can't speak for the current formula which has more cinnamon (my tub is a few years old), but I'd imagine it being pretty great too.

I just recently had a sample of the current version arrive. I don’t get a lot of cinnamon in it. Reminds me of pumpkin bread

 

[AlphaFrank75]

Please take no offense but that looks absolutely disgusting. Then again, I prefer more traditional scents and something that doesn't look like the results of a poor diet.

Disgusting?????? Are you kidding???? LOL, I find that a fresh, untouched tub looks kind of cool. If you have any kind of imagination you can see plenty of abstract images. I've often thought of starting a thread where you'd post a pic of the tub and people would respond with what they see. I know, I'm weird with a vivid imagination. And as far as the scent, it's one of my favorite seasonal scents. Although I've not smelled it, PAA Atomic Pumpkin might need to be looked at.

 

[CCS]

No, I wasn't kidding.

 

[Kyle89]

We looking, or are we smelling here??? LOL

 

[Kyle89]

 

[Guido620]

I'm awaiting an order of PAA Atomic Pumpkin. I've heard nothing but good things, I'll keep you posted after it's put to use.

 

[lak611]

I ordered the Stirling Pumpkin Spice soap and the aftershave.

I don't care how the soap looks in the container. It's the smell that matters to me.

Thanks for the recommendation. I'll let you all know how I like it when it arrives.

 

[luvmysuper]

This is how I feel this time of year.

 

[awk_m4]

Southern Witchcrafts Samhain in my opinion is ridiculously good.

 

[Tirvine]

Although I am a devout user of MDC Fougere, the scent of pumpkin spice might move me to try Arko as a way to overcome it.

 

[CCS]

While I can't speak for Stirling, I can speak to soap making. It's likely that it's hot process batching, which is a soap product that is fully saponified before being placed in its mold, or container. The consistency of a hot processed soap is that of vaseline before it cures, making it difficult to get into the container without it looking somewhat messy.

Just thought you'd be intrested.

I'm not but thanks for the explanation. It looks like what it looks like and it ain't pleasant.

 

[lak611]

I'm awaiting an order of PAA Atomic Pumpkin. I've heard nothing but good things, I'll keep you posted after it's put to use.

What shop sells that one? I'd like to give it a try as well.

 

[ChriWilson]