Which one to pick....little help.

[Cohiba]

Hey All...

First let me state....No Scotch...can't stand the stuff. Yes I have tried a lot....Aberfeldy to Dalmore...Highland Park...Auchentoshan....etc...YUCK!!!

I like American Bourbon and Whiskey...anyways.....back to the help.

I have three lined up for this weekend I want to purchase... help me pick only one or two to purchase.

1. Jack Daniels Sinatra Select: Is this a gimmick? Yes I know about the cut(inside) barrel staves to obtain extra flavor. I do like Jack...especially their Single Barrel...Jack Gold#27, double mellowed and double barreled...Jack Single Barrel-Barrel Proof(132.2 proof Mmmm good)...all good!!

In the Oklahoma City area there is only one bottle left....buy it? Special occasions? Pros and Cons please.



2. Cologne E.H. Taylor-Barrel Proof: This stuff is hard to find here in the Oklahoma City area. As soon as it hits the shelf...POOF...gone!! So I know a guy that works in my favorite liquor store that when it arrives he'll hold a bottle. Pros-Cons???



3rd. Elijah Craig Barrel Proof. Every bottle I have sampled it, it has been very good. Buy two bottles? Pros-Cons?



Comments and suggestions on these are appreciated.

 

[FL shaver]

I'd grab the Col EH Taylor. I have the Small Batch, Bottled in Bond version, and it is very good. I like just about anything from Buffalo Trace. I think you can get the others any time. Curious to know if you will be able to get the Taylor at retail, if I may be so bold.... I paid under $50 for my bottle, and feel it was worth it.

 

[Cohiba]

Retail...I'm pretty sure....before the store does their mark up!!! As you well know...E H Taylor just keeps going up and Weller 12yr old is in extremely short supply here.

 

[FL shaver]

Weller 12 is precious here, too! My son-in-law was able to obtain a bottle of this year's, and it is so good!

 

[jjking54]

+1 on the EHT ... And a bottle of EC while you're at it

 

[Doc4]

The "poof it's gone" middle one.

And Talisker 10.

First let me state....No Scotch...can't stand the stuff. Yes I have tried a lot....Aberfeldy to Dalmore...Highland Park...Auchentoshan....etc...YUCK!!!

 

[MntnMan62]

A couple more for consideration?