I started off long ago with creams & bowl...but now I pretty much face lather with soap all the time
My preferred method is lathering on the puck, inside of a mug. This method is what most people of yore probably did.
I am a face latherer 100% of the time and I use shave soaps about 99% of the time (once in a while I do use a cream)
I am almost 50/50 soaps versus creams and bowl lather 90% of the time. I like variety.