To stake further claim to that unique membership in the exclusive society of I Made My Mind Known to wit Taylor's Cologne Preference, here are the final data points. I left the One choice out intentionally.
What's Your Favorite Taylor's Cologne? Round 2!
- Thread starter guenron
- Start date
I currently have the Victorian Lime, that is all. I previously had the Sandalwood, which I didn't much care for and traded. Also had the no. 74 which was the worst smell I have ever encountered. Joel has that one now, and apparently likes it. Go figure.
I would really like to try Shave Shop and the others, though.
I would really like to try Shave Shop and the others, though.
- Thread starter
- #3
Obviously, he failed to post in the poll!Scotto said:I currently have the Victorian Lime, that is all. I previously had the Sandalwood, which I didn't much care for and traded. Also had the no. 74 which was the worst smell I have ever encountered. Joel has that one now, and apparently likes it. Go figure.
I would really like to try Shave Shop and the others, though.
I have the Saint James that I like and sold my Sandalwood that I did not like. I also have Shave Shop that I find acceptable.
- Thread starter
- #5
Amazing how folks either love or hate the Taylor's Sandalwood. No middle ground here.
In the poll I just counted "colognes" but I have a few aftershave splashes as well.
My personal favorite is Mr. Taylors, followed up by Mr. Sidney, Sandalwood, then shave shop.
My personal favorite is Mr. Taylors, followed up by Mr. Sidney, Sandalwood, then shave shop.
Does Taylor's Shave Shop cologne smell similar to the shave cream?
I really like the fragrance of the shave cream and am currently considering placing an order for the cologne.
I really like the fragrance of the shave cream and am currently considering placing an order for the cologne.
water said:
It is essentially identical.
i love shave shop....cologne and cream....
mark tssb
mark tssb
- Thread starter
- #10
As close as you can come considering the difference in carriers. BTW, my favorite Taylors fragrance.water said:
The only Taylor's scent I have tried or own is St. James Cologne and I am really enjoying it's fresh smell (love the shaving cream too). I am considering either Shave Shop, Mr. Taylor or Eton College for the next one. Too bad the company is so stingy with the samples or I'd probably have a couple more.
RVG
RVG
reginald-van-gleason said:
Tell me about it. I requested samples and they sent me 3 tiny samples of Sandalwood, Lavender, and Almond. I was looking forward to the Shave Shop, Mr. Taylor, and Eton College samples.
I currently have the Victorian Lime, that is all. I previously had the Sandalwood, which I didn't much care for and traded. Also had the no. 74 which was the worst smell I have ever encountered. Joel has that one now, and apparently likes it. Go figure.
I would really like to try Shave Shop and the others, though.
The No. 74 Original is one of my faves. That and the Mr. Taylor.
Victorian Limes and Mr Taylors are the business!
Similar threads
