Timeless Ti .95 SB
synthetic brush
Ethos soap
synthetic brush
Ethos soap
I'll generally go for creams on those days, usually TOBS (rose or Mr Taylor's) or Cyril Salter Wild Rose. I usually leave the CF cream for when I have time to appreciate it. I'll generally go for a badger, one that I'm really comfortable with, like my Ever-Ready 22mm with TGN Finest (to this day, my favorite brush). If I'm in too much of a hurry to even soak my brush, I'll use the CH2 Synthetic. On the very rare occasion I'm in a huge hurry, I'll skip the brush & cream and go for Cremo Sandalwood.
My razor's the same whether I'm going for a fast or a leisurely shave...90%+ of the time, it's my NEW SC with a Super Iridium blade. I'll sometimes vary it up with my Tradere or a slant of some kind, but nothing has ever shaved me like that NEW. Plus, it's by far the razor I'm most familiar with, and familiarity with your tools is huge when you're in a rush.
If I'm in a hurry, I'll probably default to finishing up with Nivea Sensitive, since that's a solid choice you don't have to think about too much, or Floid Amber, since that's probably my favorite aftershave. Really, aftershaves all pretty much take the same amount of time, so that step's not so important.