What would be in your Stirling Soap Sample Pack? Choose 5!

[shavetrooper]

I am ready to try out some new scents and I keep hearing about Stirling and I keep seeing them in your Shaves of the Day. So I'm super curious!

I love the classic smells, TOBS sandalwood, bay rum, classic Clubman, Cella, and the citrus scents of Lucky Tiger.

With that in mind, since I can't smell 'em all from AZ, what would you recommend I get?

And if you could pick 5 Stirling soaps, what would they be? Here are the choices offered on their website:

Almond Creame
Arkadia
Baker Street
Barbershop
Bay Rum
Ben Franklin
Bergamot Lavender
Black Cherry
Campania
Coniferous
Deep Blue Sea
Duchess
Duke
Eucalyptus Mint
Evie
Executive Man
Frozen Tundra
Gin & Tonic
Glacial Lemon Chill
Haverford
Margaritas in the Artic
Mountain Man
Naked and Smooth
Orange Chill
Ozark Mountain
Piacenza
Queen of Hearts
Ramblin' Man
Sandalwood
Sandpiper
Shadow Orchid
Sharp Dressed Man
Stirling Gentleman
Sweet Stuff
Texas on Fire
Triumph
Vanilla Sandalwood
Witchy Woman

Shave Soap Samples (Pack of 5)

Product Description Choose 5 and SAVE! These shave soap samples are a great chance to try before you buy a full jar! They're generously sized at about 1 ounce each with a diameter of about 3 inches and 1/4 inch thick. They're soft enough to press into any lathering vessel you choose. Please...

www.stirlingsoap.com

Thank you!!!

 

[Hannah's Dad]

You left out the best Stirling soaps - the Mutton tallow offerings. My top 5 sample recommendations:

1. Varen
2. Glacial Electric Sheep
3. Glastonbury
4. Executive Man
5. Sandpiper

 

[jason2]

I got

Executive man - liked
Duke - liked
Glacial lemon - didn't like. Like I rubbed a towelette I get after eating ribs all over my face
Deep blue - liked
Bay rum - nope not a bay rum person I guess

And I own Margaritas in the Arctic which at first didn't like the sweetness but liked the feel and now really like both.

I'd totally get the ones I liked as full size in the future and with added menthol.

 

[John Stetson]

I have tried almost all of the Stirling scents. If picking my top 5 for a sample pack I'd probably go...

Haverford
Deep Blue Sea
Varen
Baker St.
Executive Man

 

[shavetrooper]

You left out the best Stirling soaps - the Mutton tallow offerings. My top 5 sample recommendations:

1. Varen
2. Glacial Electric Sheep
3. Glastonbury
4. Executive Man
5. Sandpiper

I wish they had the best ones to offer in their sample pack! Thank you for your reply!

 

[muzichead]

Barbershop
Bay Rum
Margarita's in the Arctic
Sandpiper
Spice

 

[gpjoe]

Barbershop (my favorite)
Spice (never tried but it is their take on Old Spice)
Vanilla Sandalwood (never tried, but want to)

And two others I like but apparently not offered:

Pharoah's Dreamsicle (creamy orange/vanilla, my second favorite)
Glastonbury (great fall/winter scent, heavy patchouli top note)

 

[Lockback]

Barbershop
Bay Rum
Margarita's in the Arctic
Sandpiper
Spice

These would pretty much be mine. I've already tried Bay Rum (mmmm ... okay) and Margaritas In The Arctic (nice!) and really want to try Barbershop and Sandpiper.

 

[spacemonkey42]

I only have two Stirling scents, but based on that, I'd recommend Arkadia.

 

[nlife]

I love bay rum and orange chill. I'd like to try Black cherry and satsuma too. I don't have a 5th one yet

 

[JCarr]

Barbershop
Bay Rum
Black Cherry
Deep Blue Sea
Vanilla Sandalwood

 

[htownmmm]

Campania
Electric Sheep
Executive Man
Glacial Lemon Chill
Strawberry Lemonade

marty

 

[WhatAFool]

Barbershop
Margaritas in the Arctic
Deep Blue Sea
Orange Chill
Eucalyptus Mint

 

[bmiller3230]

I only have two Stirling scents, but based on that, I'd recommend Arkadia.

Arkadia, Duke, and if you like a piney scent then Ozark

 

[SlimChicken]

Scots pine
Ozark Mountain
Bay Rum
Margaritas In The Arctic
Glacial Lemon Chill (my favorite soap full stop)

 

[Three_Bravo]

I am ready to try out some new scents and I keep hearing about Stirling and I keep seeing them in your Shaves of the Day. So I'm super curious!

I love the classic smells, TOBS sandalwood, bay rum, classic Clubman, Cella, and the citrus scents of Lucky Tiger.

With that in mind, since I can't smell 'em all from AZ, what would you recommend I get?

And if you could pick 5 Stirling soaps, what would they be? Here are the choices offered on their website:

Almond Creame
Arkadia
Baker Street
Barbershop
Bay Rum
Ben Franklin
Bergamot Lavender
Black Cherry
Campania
Coniferous
Deep Blue Sea
Duchess
Duke
Eucalyptus Mint
Evie
Executive Man
Frozen Tundra
Gin & Tonic
Glacial Lemon Chill
Haverford
Margaritas in the Artic
Mountain Man
Naked and Smooth
Orange Chill
Ozark Mountain
Piacenza
Queen of Hearts
Ramblin' Man
Sandalwood
Sandpiper
Shadow Orchid
Sharp Dressed Man
Stirling Gentleman
Sweet Stuff
Texas on Fire
Triumph
Vanilla Sandalwood
Witchy Woman

Shave Soap Samples (Pack of 5)

Product Description Choose 5 and SAVE! These shave soap samples are a great chance to try before you buy a full jar! They're generously sized at about 1 ounce each with a diameter of about 3 inches and 1/4 inch thick. They're soft enough to press into any lathering vessel you choose. Please...

www.stirlingsoap.com

Thank you!!!

Bolded my choices. there are 7 but I own them all and all are stellar.
I could probably never get tired of baker st., barbershop and exec man. as my only 3.
I like exec man, huge hit with the wifey, compliments left and right on it from random folks. I like it, but others seem to like it more than me!
baker st. may be my favorite daily driver, along with barbershop

 

[Chef455]

My 5 shouldn't miss Stirling soaps in order-

1) Margs in the Arctic
2) Electric Sheep
3) Executive Man
4) Barbershop
5) Boat Drinks

Great company, terrific soaps, more than fair price, best samples in the biz and they have always tossed in a freebie with EVERY order I have purchased from them.

 

[lancre]

D-503
Electric Sheep
Executive Man
Frankincense & Myrrh
Scots Pine Sheep











Frankincense & Myrrh

 

[Curkio]

Arkadia is a must

 

[BigJ]

My choices:
Baker St.
Executive man
Barbershop
Duke
Sharp dressed man