The Veg! Far more complex than the others. My wife hates the scent out of the bottle, even decanted, but likes it on my skin. I guess I just have the right chemistry for it.
My favourite is the Clubman Original, with the Special Reserve as a close second. I also find the Classic Vanilla quite good, while The Veg is definitely NOT for me. I have no idea on the others because I've never tried.
Depends on the time of day, phase of the moon, what my psychic says and the leaves in the bottom of my tea cup. I picked Original Clubman, but I have 'em all and use them all pretty much equally.