Name your absolute favorite mentholated shaving cream.??
Dear friend, you definitely have good taste!! All the creams you mentioned are great. I also enjoy quiet a bit the European Gillette menthol shaving cream made in France.!! Sadly discontinued.Gada Cool Mint tops the list for me. LEA Menthol is pretty good, but I prefer LEA Classic - less menthol but much better scent to my nose. Proraso Green is another solid choice.
Italian Palmolive Menthol is nice, but a bit to chemical smelling to me.
That's all I've tried so far. The OP asked for creams, not soaps, do my list stops here.