I may give out a few for Christmas and i need some ideas.
Clubman original and SR.
Aqua Velva Mush and or Ice Blue.
A little steeper in price but any thing Captains Choice.
Third cheap and good would be Skinbracer...an old classic and works very well.
It's hard to beat AV. Alcohol, water, glycerin, fragrence, menthol all on the cheap.
The AV and Nivea Sensitive balm are great IMO. I'm also a Stetson man
Then a tie with Speick, Captain's Choice, Krampert's
In terms of high value (high performance at a low price point), it is hard to beat:
RazoRock Baby Blue
Razorock Balm (any scent)
Proraso ASB (any scent)
Best performer- Speick
Bedt values- AV Ice Blue, Barbasol Pacific Rush, Skin Bracer
Three brands of AS:
1st Pinaud Clubman (Classic, Musk, Lime Sec your choice all are great)
2nd Aqua Velva
3rd Captain Choice (again all are great)
Anything from St. Charles Shave products
Family Dollar Spice $1.69