There's a well used "What aftershave soap combination did you pick today?" thread but I don't believe we have a thread for shaving cream and aftershave pairings.
I haven't tried it, but Old Spice cream in a tube is still made in India. You can get it on Amazon or on several of the US shaving sites. The reviews are not bad. It is very inexpensive.Not quite on topic but I’m looking for a cream that pairs well with old spice aftershave