West Indies lathers better than Sicily?

[TacticalPanda]

Hey guys, Tallow and Steel is one of my top 2 bases along with Wholly Kaw Donkey Milk. For some reason, I've noticed that West Indies lathers more easily than Sicily and almost always produces a superior lather. Is there any meaningful difference between them ingredient wise? Have you noticed any other brands where different scents lather differently?

 

[Fly2High]

Sicily is a different formulation, if I recall. It will be the version used going forward. It all depends on how old the WI is whether it is the old or new formulation. It sounds to me like you got the old.

 

[hamleto]

I think West Indies is offered only with old formulation? Am I wrong?