This, except I currently have 6ish soaps. I did my research, fretted and fussed over the buy button, and came out on top each time. I like all the soaps I have, some are probably on a “lower tier” list of others. It’s all quite YMMV and best bang for the buck.
I'm just about where you are, albeit with less research, most likely. I have five soaps at this time: Tabac, MWF, Stirling Barbershop, and sticks of La Toja and Palmolive. No dogs in that pack. All "top tier" in my book.