Between the two Taylor's has the better ingredients list, since contains no parabens. I'm really tempted to buy a tub now! And another cream I have my eyes on is the new Simpsons Vanilla & Rose, which has true Rosa Centifolia Flower Extract and is boosted with both glycerin and shea butter.
I'll have to wait until I'm finished with my cream longevity contest (I'm in the middle of that run), but I found the unscented Simpson's cream to be excellent. I can't wait to try this new cream.