Top 5 shave soaps and aftershaves in your den

[andromeda673]

so as I cruise through my journey of wet shaving, and get a better feel of what I like and what I’m looking for and what I enjoy having. I’ve learned that certain things will always have a spot in my den, and or will be on hand. What are you guys top fives of soaps and aftershaves?

 

[GearNoir]

In no particular order.
Soaps:
CBL Wagyu Tallow base
CBL Stout base
Grooming Department Beef Tallow
Lisa’s Natural Herbal Creations Artisan base
Jeeves of Hudson St

Aftershaves:
Myrsol
Fine
Speick
Lucky Tiger
Bootlegger’s

 

[Pepin]

My top 5 soaps:
Tabac
GFT Eucris
Truefitt & Hill Sandalwood
Proraso green
Arko

My top 5 aftershaves:
Tabac
Pinaud Clubman Original
Pinaud Clubman Lilac Vegetal
Pinaud Clubman Special Reserve
TOBS Victorian Lime

 

[BigJ]

Soaps: Haslinger’s, all eight options! They are that good!

AS: Pinaud clubman, Speick, Floid vigoroso, Proraso green, Fine American blend.

And those are just the tip of the iceberg!!

 

[barko78]

I only have 3 so I’ll list them in order of preference.
1) Tabac
2) MWF
3) DR Harris

 

[kluber]

My fav soaps
Haslinger schafmilch
Wholly kaw donkey milk
MWF (but tough to lather)
Pre de Provence
Tabac
Runner up is Arko


Fav aftershaves (mostly fine)
Fine Italian Citrus
Fine Fresh Vetiver
Fine platinum
Executive Shaving balm
TOBS sandalwood

 

[Macfrommichigan]

Simple tastes.

Haslinger; MWF; Cade; D.R. Harris lavender.

AV musk, Old Spice, Barbasol Brisk.

 

[Luecke2326]

I'll bite!!
Soaps:

1. Tabac
2. Martin De Candre(Any)
3. Barrister and Mann(Any)
4. Proraso(any)
5. Speick

Aftershaves:

1. Proraso Green
2. Speick
3. Vintage Aqua Velva
4. Lilac Vegetal
5. Floid Vigoroso
   
6. Honorable mention Vintage Old Spice

 

[Canadian Mountain Man]

Favorite creams/soaps:



Favorite aftershaves, in alphabetical order but my ATF happens to be at the top:
Alt-Innsbruck - EDT
Fine - American Blend Aftershave Splash
Montblanc - Presence Cologne
RazoRock - Blue Fougere Aftershave
Tabac - Original EDT

 

[JamesBlades]

My top 5 soaps:
Tabac
GFT Eucris
Truefitt & Hill Sandalwood
Proraso green
Arko

Is that the current formulation of GFT Eucris?

 

[Pepin]

Is that the current formulation of GFT Eucris?

I finished it this year. I think it was from 2014 or 2013.
Will buy a replacement. I still have the puck of violet from GFT.

 

[sscob1]

Arko
Tabac
Proraso Green
Stirling Soap Company Executive Man
Razorock XXX

 

[AimlessWanderer]

Soap:
1) Mitchell's Wool Fat
2) Palmolive

Remaining three slots vacant

Aftershave:
1) Nivea Sensitive balm

Remaining four slots vacant, although I am experimenting with homemade aftershave.

While I've had success with other soaps and postshave stuff, I've not found anything else besides those three products that I feel I need to replenish or keep stock of.

 

[ShavePastor]

It's getting harder to do these days, but my current top 5 Soaps in my den are:

B&M Reserve
Declaration Grooming (bison tallow base)
Midnight & Two
Sudsy Soapery
Shannon's
*don't know how to fit these into the list but they need to be in there also- Wholly Kaw, Noble Otter, WSP FT, Fine, Mike's, Haslinger, Stirling..........

Top 5 aftershaves:
B&M Reserve
Fine
Henri et Victoria (Nautilus & Duc de Santal)
WCS Gatsby (made by PAA w/ alum)
WSP

 

[Pivo Slump]

Pinaud whiskey woods
Brut
Fliod vigaroso
Fine l'orange
Bay rum I'm not sure which one yet, I have'nt tried them all.

 

[JB1963]

A&E, Wholly Kaw, Barrister and Mann, Declaration grooming

 

[Junker Jörg]

Arko, Arko, Arko, Arko, Speick
(The grown-man's version of Duck, Duck, Goose... or Duck, Duck, Gray Duck if you're from Minnesota.)

 

[syngent]

Top 5 is the topic

Stick to that.

Please.

 

[786 MIRACLE]

Top 5 soaps:

1-Wholly Kaw: King of Oud
2-Grooming Dept: Mallard Kulfi
3-Eufros: Zanzibar
4-Oleo: Windy City
5-Stirling: Barbershop

AfterShave

1-Pinaud: Clubman
2-Chatillon Lux: La Foret Li Liguest
3-Proraso: both green/red
4-Stirling: Executive man
5-Eufros: Fougere balm

 

[ike]

No special order:

Soap
Art of Shaving
D.R. Harris
Haslinger
Soap Commander

A/s
D.R.Harris
Windsor
Pink
Bay Rum
Speick
Art of Shaving