Antica Barbieria Colla Apricot Hull Aftershave Balm
Top 5 Aftershaves?
- Thread starter discerningbev
- Start date
Ogallala limes and peppercorn bay rum
paa atomic age bay rum
stirling piacenza
pinaud whiskey woods
brut
paa atomic age bay rum
stirling piacenza
pinaud whiskey woods
brut
My five favorites never change.
1. Spicy
2. Woodsy
3. Leathery
4. Citrusy
5. Floral
1. Spicy
2. Woodsy
3. Leathery
4. Citrusy
5. Floral
Ive got the 70th Anniversary and Manna di Sicilia. They are excellent. Both make my face feel amazing. I probably won’t buy the 70th A again bc the scent is good but doesn’t blow me away for the extra money. MdS is worth every penny. Great complex scent and my wife loves it too. I will try the Felce Arromatica next.
EclipseRedRing
I smell like a Christmas pudding
Vintage Faberge Brut
Vintage Shulton Old Spice
Vintage Yardley Black Label
Tabac
Floid Vigoroso
Vintage Shulton Old Spice
Vintage Yardley Black Label
Tabac
Floid Vigoroso
Well after more than two years, will stay with my top 5.
Tabac
Geo F. Trumper Spanish Leather
Pinaud Clubman original
TOBS Victorian Lime
Alt Innsbruck
Tabac
Geo F. Trumper Spanish Leather
Pinaud Clubman original
TOBS Victorian Lime
Alt Innsbruck
Like the hot & cold extremes...
Fine Snakebite
Ogallala Bay Rum (special reserve)
DRH Arlington & Windsor
Fine Snakebite
Ogallala Bay Rum (special reserve)
DRH Arlington & Windsor
1. Stirling Executive Man
2. Stirling Agar
3. PAA Sauvage clone
4. Stirling Sandpiper
5. PAA AA Bay Rum
2. Stirling Agar
3. PAA Sauvage clone
4. Stirling Sandpiper
5. PAA AA Bay Rum
Not in order
Sante Homme (Aloe Vera)
Sante Homme II (Acai Berry & Caffeine)
Proraso Green
Proraso Red
Speick Active
Sante Homme II (Acai Berry & Caffeine)
Proraso Green
Proraso Red
Speick Active
1. Barbedeaux
The scent is bad, like really bad on this stuff. After 30 seconds it goes away and leaves your face feeling like a million bucks. You can follow up with whatever scented splash/balm you prefer. This is the best face feel on any aftershave I have tried, and I have tried alot of them. I recommend this to anyone who has sensitive skin or suffers from razor bumps or ingrown hairs.
2. A&E Asian Plum (Favorite Scent)
3. Floid Vigoroso (Ticks all the "classic" boxes for me scent wise, and leaves your face feeling smooth.)
4. Stirling Margaritas In the Arctic (All the Stirling splashes I own are very good, I just like this scent the most.)
5. Anything Barrister and Mann
*Honorable Mention*
6. Proraso Green
The scent is bad, like really bad on this stuff. After 30 seconds it goes away and leaves your face feeling like a million bucks. You can follow up with whatever scented splash/balm you prefer. This is the best face feel on any aftershave I have tried, and I have tried alot of them. I recommend this to anyone who has sensitive skin or suffers from razor bumps or ingrown hairs.
2. A&E Asian Plum (Favorite Scent)
3. Floid Vigoroso (Ticks all the "classic" boxes for me scent wise, and leaves your face feeling smooth.)
4. Stirling Margaritas In the Arctic (All the Stirling splashes I own are very good, I just like this scent the most.)
5. Anything Barrister and Mann
*Honorable Mention*
6. Proraso Green
Proraso Green
Afta original
Jovan Musk
Barbasol Brisk/Skin Bracer (same exact scent)
Clubman Pinaud Vanilla
Afta original
Jovan Musk
Barbasol Brisk/Skin Bracer (same exact scent)
Clubman Pinaud Vanilla
Original Stetson
Pinaud Clubman Lilac Vegetal
Bootlegger's El Dorado
Tabac
Bootlegger's Bay Rum
Spanish Aqua Velva
Pinaud Clubman Lilac Vegetal
Bootlegger's El Dorado
Tabac
Bootlegger's Bay Rum
Spanish Aqua Velva
1A) Fine L'Orange Noir - when I want a nice fragrance
1B) Speick - when I just want something light and refreshing
2+) any of a host of excellent options depending on my mood - variety is the spice of life!
1B) Speick - when I just want something light and refreshing
2+) any of a host of excellent options depending on my mood - variety is the spice of life!
Declaration Grooming, Chiseled Face, Chatillon Lux, Australian Private Reserve, Barrister & Mann (Deltus or Reserve)
