Top 5 Aftershaves?

[JCarr]

1) Bootlegger's El Dorado
2) Bootlegger's Bay Rum
3) Pinaud Whiskey Woods
4) Atomic Age Bay Rum
5) Colonel Conk Bay Rum

Update:
1) Barrister and Mann Bay Rum
2) Phoenix Clasico Bay Rum
3) Bootlegger's El Dorado
4) Phoenix Atomic Age Bay Rum
5) Phoenix Space Nog

 

[ksblazer]

Epsilon
La Toja
Fine L'Orange
Speick
Trumpers Sandalwood

 

[Ron R]

Update: No real order- Jan 1st 2020
1: Fine Fresh Vetiver- just a great aroma.
2: Razorock XXX- reminds of freshness!
3: Razorock "The Dead Sea" new and really like it. Hard to describe but is awesome.
4: Avon "True gent" cologne- tobacco vanillia .....ingredients - old barber shop scents of the past I remember!
has some staying power so I dilute it with some witch hazel in a atomizer 1:4 ratio. New to my collection.
5: Proraso red sandal Wood- nice pleasant scent

May 13 -2019
1:Razorock Amici reminds me of my youth chewing pink bubble gum blowing bubbles=red grape fruit
2 Proraso red sandal wood
3:FINE fresh vetiver
4:Razorock emperor
5:Nivea freshness aftershave- it not long lasting but its OK

 

[pbrmhl]

1. Anything Chatillon Lux
2. Anything PAA
3. Anything Wm Neumann
4. Derby City Chop Shop
5. Tabac

It's interesting to look back at my favorites from a couple of years ago. Today, I would say:

1. Anything Chatillon Lux
2. Anything Maol Grooming
3. Anything PAA
4. Vintage Brut by Faberge
5. Sebum Gold

 

[OAK3x]

Pre de Provence Shea Butter Enriched Men's After Shave Balm

 

[ask4Edge]

Update:

1) Hermès
2) Caron
3) No.88
4) Windsor (drh)
5) Lotion Opaline

HM: Eucris

 

[RigelDust]

B&M 42
Wholly Kaw King of Oud
T&S Madagascar
A&E Grecian Horse
Southern Witchcrafts Tres Marres

 

[Pepin]

Tabac
Pinaud Clubman Original
GFT Spanish Leather
TOBS Eton College
Floid Vigarroso

 

[tulsamanny]

Bootlegger's Bay Rum
Ogallala Bay Rum
CC Cat O' Nine
RR Tuscan Oud
Derby City Chop Shop Winter Reserve

 

[Luc]

Proraso Green
Mennen Skin Bracer
Aqua Velva Sport
Clubman Citrus Musk
Brut (euro version)

If I can get my hands on Japanese Mandom and MG5 they would be on top of the list!

 

[Demaratus]

Proraso Green
Mennen Skin Bracer
Aqua Velva Sport
Clubman Citrus Musk
Brut (euro version)

If I can get my hands on Japanese Mandom and MG5 they would be on top of the list!

I love Mandom! You can get it on Amazon sometimes at a not crazy price.

Haven’t had the luck yet sorh MG5, though. How does it compare to Mandom?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[BigD]

Of what I own;

1. Old Spice
2. Tabac Original
3. Pinaud Clubman Special Reserve
4. Brut
5. Proraso Red

Honorable mention;

• Aqua Velva Ice Blue (US and Eur)
• Captain's Choice
• Colonel Conk

 

[Luc]

I love Mandom! You can get it on Amazon sometimes at a not crazy price.

Haven’t had the luck yet sorh MG5, though. How does it compare to Mandom?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

MG5 is different compared to Mandom. Last I heard, MG5 was made in Vietnam. The product became average. I’m not sure that you can get a bottle made in Japan anymore. It still an interesting scent, but not as good as the Japanese version

 

[Demaratus]

MG5 is different compared to Mandom. Last I heard, MG5 was made in Vietnam. The product became average. I’m not sure that you can get a bottle made in Japan anymore. It still an interesting scent, but not as good as the Japanese version

Good to know, thanks. I’ll stick with Mandom and Bravas for my Japanese fix.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Chan Eil Whiskers]

Happy shaves,

Jim

 

[The situational shaver]

It all depends on the situation. Since it’s winter, I’ll stick to my winter scents.
High humidity- Clubman musk, V.I. bay rum
Low humidity- Master topaz, A.V. musk, the Cptn’s bay rum
Normal humidity- Jovan musk, Col.Conk’s bay rum, and of course, Old Spice.

 

[pbrmhl]

View attachment 1052148

View attachment 1052149

View attachment 1052150


View attachment 1052151

View attachment 1052152

Happy shaves,

Jim

I have all of those. In my den, The Beach is near the top. It’s going with me to Hawaii next month, along with Lisa’s Florida Freeze shaving soap. They play well together when they meet in Maui.

 

[Bobby Barbasol]

Aqua Velva Classic Ice Blue
English Leather
Brut
Skin Bracer
Old Spice

Honorable mentions:
Clubman After Shave Lotion
Stetson

 

[Drseid]

1)vintage Polo by Ralph Lauren
2)vintage Giorgio for Men by Giorgio Beverly Hills
3)Glastonbury by Stirling
4)Colonia by Asylum Shave Works (SV)
5)Manna di Sicilia by SV

 

[Tillerman7]

My list would be: 1) Floid Vigoroso 2) Stirling Sandalwood 3) Stirling Barbershop 4) Stirling Baker St. 5) Proraso Green

What say the board?

1) Proraso Green
2) Stirling Spice
3) Polo Blue
4) Musco Real
5) Stirling Island Man