I asked a client (seventy year old gentleman) which bay rum he used, sure that what I was smelling was a much better version of the classic than my Pinaud's Virgin Island Bay Rum. Surprisingly he said it was Paul Sebastian cologne. Turns out it is a spicy/woody/citrus deal that, to me, smells like a quality bay rum. Anyone familiar with this stuff. It smells much better than the bay rum the janitor at my gym wears!