What's new

The Gold Dollar of the kitchen?

Legion

OTF jewel hunter
Staff member
For non straight razor guys, Gold Dollar razors are VERY cheap Chinese brand straight razors. The care in manufacturing them is practically zero, but the steel is pretty good so, if you can be bothered, you can turn them into decent shavers. Some guys even go so far as to use them as a blank canvas for modifications, and truly create art from them.

I think I may have found the kitchen equivalent.

I live in a share house, so my nice hand made Japanese knife does not live in the kitchen. I will bring it out if I am getting serious, but usually it lives safely hidden in its box so no one ruins it by using it to cut up a frozen whole chicken and then throwing it in the dishwasher. This could happen.

So I wanted a decent sized carbon knife that was a bit more "expendable", and would be ready at hand for quick jobs. I found Ontario's butcher knife on ebay, and for about $20 posted from the States, it seemed to fit the bill.

Well, it arrived today and my first impression is "you get what you pay for". The edge grind on this thing looked like it was done by someone who was fired from the Gold Dollar factory for a lack of attention to detail. It is 1095 steel though, and if that stuff is tempered properly it usually takes a good edge.

After about half an hour on the hones I decided I needed to stop messing about, and went and got out the Dremmel. I completely changed (fixed) the edge geometry, and then knocked all the sharp corners off the handle while I was about it. I sanded the handle up, gave it a nicer bees wax finish, and honed the blade to 6k, then CrOx. It now tree tops hairs, and I think it should hold the edge pretty well, as the steel seemed quite hard.

So, there you have it. For you guys who are a bit handy, and want a knife which will outlast you for minimal cost, check these things out. They are great value, if you have the energy to do some work yourself. I want a couple more now.

 
I have the exact same model and I love the thing. I had the same experience when mine arrived - the finish was rough as hell but with a bit of work it ended up damned sharp. The edge retention is awesome, I've used mine to baton wood and after a quick few passes on a steel it was shaving arm hair again

Did you just use a grinding wheel for fixing up that edge? I worked mine on a stone and could definitely have done a better job
 
I had a set of those, but they got destroyed from getting wet. I saw a set at my local antique store last week, I might go back and get them. I remember being able to put a razor sharp edge on them.
 
that's a nice idea for a project, I'd never thought of that - thanks David

@ Argonaut - there are a number of new and vintage Ontario knives on ebay if you do a quick search, a few in sets also, good luck
 
I have one of those that is on the list to get cleaned up and given an edge. I have developed a habit of picking up vintage carbon blades from when I get drug along with the GF for the weekend antiquing. It is pretty crazy the prices you can get away with paying for some very very good blade just because they are a little oxidized and not stainless. I have a fair amount of blades for less than $7.50/ knife and have a couple more located that I am patiently waiting for the price to come down lol. Another nice thing is people tend not to reach right for them to use because they just thing they are old dull kitchen knives even though they are usually some of the sharpest.

Right now I am on the hunt for a vintage Forgecraft Chef's knife but I haven't been having much luck locally.
 

Legion

OTF jewel hunter
Staff member
I have the exact same model and I love the thing. I had the same experience when mine arrived - the finish was rough as hell but with a bit of work it ended up damned sharp. The edge retention is awesome, I've used mine to baton wood and after a quick few passes on a steel it was shaving arm hair again

Did you just use a grinding wheel for fixing up that edge? I worked mine on a stone and could definitely have done a better job

Just the grinding wheel on my dremel, which I hold in place clamped in my bicycle work stand. The job would have been a lot faster and easier if I still had my belt grinder.
 

Alacrity59

Wanting for wisdom
I really like the Lee Valley Peasant knife. About $30 CDN but it comes in pretty darn good and sharp shape. High carbon steel knives are amazingly easy to keep very sharp. Smile at them and they rust though. You gotta wipe them after use.
 
Top Bottom