Terre D'hermes Edp or EdT?

[shakin_jake]

Hi Gents!...I've had a hankerin to try this named frag...read about it off and on, & am thinking about pulling the trigger but wanted to hear from those of you that own or have owned/used both the Edp and the EdT. Which one to go with? Which do you prefer since you've used both. I've read the reviews on basenotes and it seems the EdP is preferred, but again, I wanted to hear from my B&B Brothers that have used both, what say you? Which one and why?


Best,


Jake
Reddick Fla.

 

[Lamb Root]

To me EDP has a little fuller and more unison appear, and better projection. Therefore EDP. But EDT and AS are also great. In summer I'd go with an after shave.

 

[shakin_jake]

Thanks!, that was a quick reply! So this is not a good summer scent...the EdP?


Best,


Jake
Reddick Fla.

 

[Timmy Dee]

Thanks!, that was a quick reply! So this is not a good summer scent...the EdP?

I think the Parfum works ok in the summer, but the brighter, zestier citrus of the EDT (the Parfum is more heavy on the woods, whereas the EDT is more orange and vetiver) makes it a better summer scent.

Like Ivan, I prefer the Parfum quite a bit more than the EDT. I find it richer and warmer, where the EDT has a sharpness that reduces its appeal slightly.

That being said, I think each has its merits. I own both and wear them about equally - coming into winter, though, I'm about to start using the Parfum a lot more.
The longevity on both is staggering - 8 hours or so, with a slight advantage to the EDT.

 

[tehtimmeh]

There's not a world of difference. If I had to choose only one, I would go with the richer, deeper pure parfum (there is not an EdP).

The brighter citrus notes combined with the lighter body of the EdT make it a better choice for the warm weather, however.

 

[Schad]

I dont have enough experience w/ specifically this one, but I've come to learn that the EDP isn't always better. Basenotes wisdom is always choose the stronger scent (EDP over EDT), but I have come to learn that in warm weather the EDTs fit better.

 

[ScentFreak]

Pure parfume version gives me headache.
yes it will give you better projection and longevity but its too overpowering for my taste.

If I had to choose between the two, I d choose neither. If you can afford it go for Montale Red Vetyver. Much better scent with better performance.

 

[demcav]

I prefer the pure perfume not only because it is deeper and rounder, but also because I find it does NOT project as much as the edt, especially in the opening. My experience is that the perfume is more similar to the dry down of the edt, and without the "louder" flinty projection of the edt's opening. And the perfume is comfortably wearable in the heat and humidity during summer in S. LA.

 

[shakin_jake]

okay...been reading BN discussions (recent) of TDH *and* Montvale Red Vet till my head explody. Seems there are many that are upset with a reformulation (TDH)..., both EdT, and EdP

Red Vet getting mostly + comments. I had no idea what I was walking into


Best,


Jake
Reddick Fla.

 

[dilney]

I find Montale Red Vetyver and Terre d'Hermès are very different animals. If you like Terre d'Hermès, doesn't mean you'll like the Montale as well. They share some similarities, but the Montale was too sweet and the patchouli base was far too strong for my taste and I sold it.

I prefer the drier/woodier base of TdH. I finished a sample of it and I still plan on getting a full bottle (like you, I'm undecided between pure parfum and EdT).

 

[Schad]

I love Montale Red Vetyver

 

[stewartmuir]

I've tried both the EdT and the EdP. They're not all that different, but overall I'd say the EdT is better balanced. The EdP turns to cedar a bit too quickly for me, and although it smells great and long-lasting, I find myself longing for more of the mineralic top-notes. A combined wearing of both might be perfect!

 

[global_dev]

I dont think you can go wrong with either the parfum or edt.

 

[tehtimmeh]

okay...been reading BN discussions (recent) of TDH *and* Montvale Red Vet till my head explody. Seems there are many that are upset with a reformulation (TDH)..., both EdT, and EdP

Red Vet getting mostly + comments. I had no idea what I was walking into


Best,


Jake
Reddick Fla.

Jake, I recommend getting samples of all 3 and trying them out. You'll be able to tell which works best for you. As to the reformulation hysteria, that's a bit of a regular occurrence with the BN crowd on just about every scent imaginable. Some of it is very true and some of it is blown completely out of proportion IMO.

As for TdH, I am not sufficiently intimately familiar enough with the new vs. vintage formulations enough to opine, but I recently underwent a 3-way test using all recent formulations. Before starting my tests, I was sure that the Montale would be the clear winner, but for me it ended up not being the case. I actually preferred them in this order: TdH Pure Parfum > Montale > TdH EdT.

That obviously isn't going to be the same preference for everyone. Only you know your nose, so order a few samples and see what works best on you.

 

[p.m.a.]

I find strong similarities between TDH, Red Vetyver, and also Tom Ford Grey Vetiver. To me they all share a sickly sweet component that fouls up the vetiver. I've tried to enjoy them, but just find all of these to be intolerable. It's a strange for me because I'm a huge fan of vetiver and these scents receive many accolades. Seems that I'm in a minority, so chances are that you will enjoy. Good luck!

 

[rum]

Getting this thread back on topic....

- The EdT is great for the summer months, applied lightly. I find it really works with the summer heat and can project/last quite a bit.
- The Parfum is all smoother and nicely rounded off. For me, this works best in the cooler months, specifically autumn/winter and especially here in the UK during those seasons. As others have said, the woody flint (mineral) notes are more pronounced in this.

I have loved and owned both since they were released.

As to the comparisons with other fragrances mentioned above - I find this to be quite inaccurate. TdH has been unique for a while now and in my opinion nothing really comes close. Granted, Grey Vetiver and Sycomore even, are 'woody' scents, but not of the structure of the Hermes. They lack the flint/mineral note which to me is very unique in TdH; they do not have the smooth grapefruit in the opening (something the reformulation of TdH has toned down and makes most think that TdH contians an orange note). As for Red Vetyver, I think this one is miles off from TdH and does not even come close to the quality of TdH - it smells like pure Iso E Super to my nose...

 

[litespeedone]

I love the EdT and recently picked up the EdP. To me, they are so similar that it was redundant to own both, although obviously some others here don't agree with that. (I just sold my bottle of EdT and kept the EdP.)

That said, I do agree with some of the above comments. My nose is not as refined as others here, but I would describe the EdT as "sharper" and more pungent, while the EdP is a little "smoother". I think both are wonderful warm-weather scents.

 

[shakin_jake]

Jake, I recommend getting samples of all 3 and trying them out. You'll be able to tell which works best for you. As to the reformulation hysteria, that's a bit of a regular occurrence with the BN crowd on just about every scent imaginable. Some of it is very true and some of it is blown completely out of proportion IMO.

As for TdH, I am not sufficiently intimately familiar enough with the new vs. vintage formulations enough to opine, but I recently underwent a 3-way test using all recent formulations. Before starting my tests, I was sure that the Montale would be the clear winner, but for me it ended up not being the case. I actually preferred them in this order: TdH Pure Parfum > Montale > TdH EdT.

That obviously isn't going to be the same preference for everyone. Only you know your nose, so order a few samples and see what works best on you.

~~~~I agree Tim, getting samples of all three is the next logical step. Who would you recommend for me to use to obtain all three samples in one fell swoop?, and I would assume the decant vendor would use juice from the stock I'd probably end up buying, yes? IOW, what's currently available?



Best,


Jake
Reddick Fla.

 

[p.m.a.]

I was surprised at the mention of getting the thread "back on topic", especially since it appears that OP was encouraged to learn about alternatives such as Red Vetyver. Contrary to what has been stated, it seems that really only one person has mentioned "woody flint (mineral)...flint/mineral" and I don't even know what that means. As far as iso e super is concerned, TdH is apparently loaded with the stuff. As to the natural meandering of any given thread goes, I would recommend that one simply take what they like from it and politely leave the rest, as the obligatory YMMV applies.

 

[Chuck Sirloin]

You guys are forgetting D.R. Harris' "Windsor". It's very similar to TdH, but I get way more compliments on it than when I wear my Terre di Hermes. It' s a lot cheaper, too.