Strongest tobacco scent

[pbfde]

Hi Ive got or had these AS:
Clubman SR (dont find it truly tobacco smell)
Tabac (too floral)
Stirling Gentleman (too soft in smell not like a smelly cigar)

I want a stronger, edgier tobacco/cigar smell. Ive read some comments about a Maggards tobacco scent. Would that be more to my liking, do you think, or can you recommend something else. Id be interested in an edc too (but probably not a very expensive one).

 

[mglindo]

I just ordered some samples from these guys: Phoenix Artisan Accoutrements, where I got some samples of which one was called Briar and another called Cavendish. No idea what they are like but they sounded good enough to try. Check them out as samples are only $.99 so it's a good deal.


Mike

 

[Andy77]

Barrister and Mann- Roam. All tobacco and flint.

Of course is was discontinued 3 years ago. I’m a big help!

 

[sarimento1]

Cavendish is pipe tobacco.

 

[Graybeard57]

I haven't tried them all, but you ought to try Wet Shaving Products Tobacco. Excellent tobacco and bay rum. Perhaps you can find a sample online.

 

[OkieStubble]

Hi Ive got or had these AS:
Clubman SR (dont find it truly tobacco smell)
Tabac (too floral)
Stirling Gentleman (too soft in smell not like a smelly cigar)

I want a stronger, edgier tobacco/cigar smell. Ive read some comments about a Maggards tobacco scent. Would that be more to my liking, do you think, or can you recommend something else. Id be interested in an edc too (but probably not a very expensive one).

Bootlegger's Perfecto

Bootlegger's Maduro

 

[Esetter]

RR Puros is quite cigar-ish.
Another great one is Henri et Victoria "Cognac and Cuban cigar"

 

[pbfde]

I googled Bootleggers Perefecto. Its a homebrew AS mix by a forum member and one of the ingredient AS, the tobacco scent AS, is unobtainable. The cites to a discontinued Barrister fragrance and untried samples are also not useful.

 

[pbfde]

RR Puros looks like its one I want. Currently sold out on Italian Barber site.

 

[pbfde]

The Henri et one also looks like I would want and is for sale at Maggard.

 

[NEEHOOYA]

I would suggest two great soaps:

WSP - Tobacco (Either Vegan or Fromula T) - yes they offer samples.
Wholly Kaw - Merchant of Tobacco - they also offer samples.

 

[Esetter]

The Henri et one also looks like I would want and is for sale at Maggard.

You won't be disappointed. Are you in the U.S. or Canada?

 

[md1234]

RR Santa Maria del Fiore (Tuscan cigar)
Cuba red EdT
Cuba royal EdT

 

[ClubmanFan]

RR Puros looks like its one I want. Currently sold out on Italian Barber site.

Groomatorium has 4 in stock. You might want to try Chiseled Face Cedar and Spice. There's something to it that reminds me of pipe tobacco.

 

[pbfde]

You won't be disappointed. Are you in the U.S. or Canada?

I am in US.

 

[pbfde]

I would suggest two great soaps:

WSP - Tobacco (Either Vegan or Fromula T) - yes they offer samples.
Wholly Kaw - Merchant of Tobacco - they also offer samples.

Sorry, not looking for soaps, only AS or edc. My thinking is non to get inundated with soaps, not to look for different fragrances with soaps, only with AS and or edc, so as not to multipy my addiction.

 

[mglindo]

I just got in my samples from Phoenix Artisan Accourtrements and although I don't smoke and don't know what these tobacco aftershaves are supposed to smell like, the Briar and Cavendish samples were delicious. They smelled almost good enough to eat.


Mike

 

[NEEHOOYA]

Sorry, not looking for soaps, only AS or edc. My thinking is non to get inundated with soaps, not to look for different fragrances with soaps, only with AS and or edc, so as not to multipy my addiction.

My bad, meant AS.
Check them out, I like WSP aftershave a little more than WK.
WSP has two versions of AS, regular and one with menthol.

 

[Gdawgs]

Mickey Lee's Grand Havana is excellent. My bottle is running low and it saddens me.

 

[Mr. Bonney]

Avon Oland has a really pronounced tobacco middle note to me.