I've tried Mama Bear's Aged Spice and love it. Are there any others? Please don't suggest the original Old Spice soap. I know it exists, but I don't want to pay $30+ for it.
Old Spice + menthol..........You can get the The Shave Den's Old Spice Type soap for $6.99:
Matthew, I've found that the Old Spice "homage" soaps by the artisan crafters here fall in to one of two categories: they either smell like the real deal but don't perform anything like it, or they perform well but don't smell like the real deal. I have yet to find a suitable replacement, though Sue at SCS makes the closest yet with her New Spice bar. Mama Bear's Aged Spice performs well, but it doesn't remind me of the Shulton soap at all.