I have tried the aftershave and found it a very pleasing scent, but soap...sadly I haven't had the opportunity.
I've also tried the splash but not the soap. I imagine many have, as it's still in production whereas the soap isn't.
I find the A/S scent OK but not great. It's a scent I'd rather smell than smell like, if that makes any sense. The notes listed on Basenotes for it do not match what I get from the stuff at all. The overall experience makes me wonder whether the main draw of the SIM stick for some was that it was Tabac lather while not being Tabac.