Not to me. Tabac and Sherlock are opposite sides of the scent spectrum imo. Sherlock is dark and dirty, Tabac is powdery and kind of floral.Found this thread while looking for what other folks thought about Chiseled Face's Sherlock as I just tried it for the first time today. I get more of an outdoorsy feel than being inside around books and periodicals. Makes me think of working in a garden or strolling on damp grass. But I do like it for sure. Is this at all what Tabac smells like?