TOBS Organic is unscented. Nice and creamy too
Cella Crema de Barba Rapida is amazing of its type.
Comes in a 150g tube. Easy to squeeze out the right amount. No brush needed. Just rub it on. A brush can be used, though, if you prefer. It’s the slickest substance known to man or woman. Virtually no fragrance, maybe slightly floral-soapy. As a bonus, it leaves no soap scum in the sink.
Certainly NIVEA sensitive fits the bill, great performer all around and pretty good value.... Also, neither of us are BIG fragrance people, so a light fragrance would be preferable. I'd sure appreciate any advice and direction, thank you!
Gillette Pure isn't bad, and I've found it in brick and mortar stores.
If lather isn't a must for you I'd also second the recommendation of the Cremo products. My wife has used it in the past when her favorite gel has run out.