What's new

Settling In

P

PortsmouthDavid

Gents --

I first got into wet shaving (brush, DE, shaving soap) back in the 70s, so I have a long track record with this process. I've tried other stuff along the way, but always gravitated back to the DE / wet shave.

This year, after internet reading including Badger & Blade, I started trying all sorts of variations and permutations on razors, blades, creams, soaps, etc. to try to boost my DE performance.

Despite having been at this for a long time, I think I've found my new "sweet spot."

FWIW, I have the classic worst-case shaving scenario -- extremely thick, tough beard, UNBELIEVABLY, RIDICULOUSLY sensitive skin, and a job that requires me to shave every day.

So, here's where I'm settling in for now. It doesn't mean I'll never try another product (because I'm sure I will), but unlike some folks here I don't like switching everything every day. I like more consistency. So here's my present line up.

1) Razor -- 1947 Gillette Aristocrat. A thing of beauty. A very mild-mannered but effective all around DE. I prefer it to the Merkur HD I had been using previously. Feels very solid and traditional, and shaves like a dream. Very close and comfortable and almost impossible to nick myself with.

2) Blade -- Swedish Gillette. I think I tried everything on the market this year. Before this process I'd been using Merkurs and American Gillettes, but recently I've tested Derby, Israeli Personna, Feather, and Wilkinson Swords. I still use the Israelis sometimes, as an extra-mild option (especially if my face needs a little respite). But for me the best all-rounder is the Swede. It's extremely sharp, extremely consistent, very long-lasting, and somehow quite kind and forgiving as well. Works great for me.

3) Soap. D.R. Harris (Arlington). This is a superb product, and gives me a great shave. No irritation at all, and it's very fast and close. Works much better for me than (for example) Williams or the other mass-market soaps. Smells nice too.

4) Cream. Nancy Boy. I really like this stuff better than the English creams I've tried. The pepperminty smell is way-cool. The "cushion" is out of this world. It gives me a great and super-comfortable shave for days when I want a cream instead of a soap. (My only gripe is the sort of in-your-face gay marketing aspect . . . i.e., the "Nancy Boy" name, the blog on the web-site with its gay politics, the "tested on boyfriends not animals" statement, etc. But I'll overlook all the silly sexual politics because the product is so great.)

All of the above are changes/refinements to the DE regimen I'd followed in the past. What I didn't change was my brush (a fairly large-ish super badger no-name brush that someone gave me a few years ago when my 1970s vintage "pure" badger brush that I bought in Europe for a few dollars finally cracked up and gave up the ghost!). It works fine and I haven't seen the need to go through a lot of testing of new brushes. (But I still miss my little dark-gray "pure" badger brush).

So that's where I'm settling in. These are really Primo products that seem to do a terrific job for me. I can really see the difference in more consistent, less-irritating shaves. Funny how, after all these years, a few tweaks to the line-up has really boosted the performance!

David
 
Welcome to B & B David!

It's nice to hear that someone has found their "sweet spot" as far as products go. This helps in preventing a bad case of SCAD, BAD, & RAD.

I believe that most who find their sweet spot, then acquire more products to see if they can improve on that. for myself, my sweet spot is more of a moving target so there are times that I change my ingredients.

again, Welcome!


Marty
 
Good for you, David. It is, after all, about finding the best shave you can get. I wish I could be satisfied with a little bit more consistency in my routine. My shaves have been very good for quite some time, but the desire to try new things is still going strong.
 
Ditto--it takes real willpower for me not to pull the trigger on each new "best" thing I see described on these boards. I'm struggling against my urge to purchase a dozen Mama Bear soaps right now!
 
"FWIW, I have the classic worst-case shaving scenario -- extremely thick, tough beard, UNBELIEVABLY, RIDICULOUSLY sensitive skin, and a job that requires me to shave every day."

This describes my situation perfectly. I hope I find the perfect combonation of products to get good, irritation-free shaves 6 times per week.
 
P

PortsmouthDavid

Christoph said:
"FWIW, I have the classic worst-case shaving scenario -- extremely thick, tough beard, UNBELIEVABLY, RIDICULOUSLY sensitive skin, and a job that requires me to shave every day."

This describes my situation perfectly. I hope I find the perfect combonation of products to get good, irritation-free shaves 6 times per week.

Christoph -

Since you find yourself in the same boat, you might consider trying the line-up I outlined above. The problem for us tough beard / sensitive skin gents is that we need sharp products to deal with the tought beard, but those same items can rough up our skin. So it's a delicate balancing act. That's why I'm so pleased with the gentle razor / sharp blade combination. And of course, choosing excellent shaving soaps / creams is a big leg-up as well. Anyway, I pass it along "FWIW." You can pick up a Gillette Aristocrat on e-bay or here: http://countrycc.com/gillette_safety_razors_reconditioned.html and the Swedish Gillette blades are available at www.auravita.com.

Hope this helps and good luck. David
 
PortsmouthDavid said:
Christoph -

Since you find yourself in the same boat, you might consider trying the line-up I outlined above. The problem for us tough beard / sensitive skin gents is that we need sharp products to deal with the tought beard, but those same items can rough up our skin. So it's a delicate balancing act. That's why I'm so pleased with the gentle razor / sharp blade combination. And of course, choosing excellent shaving soaps / creams is a big leg-up as well. Anyway, I pass it along "FWIW." You can pick up a Gillette Aristocrat on e-bay or here: http://countrycc.com/gillette_safety_razors_reconditioned.html and the Swedish Gillette blades are available at www.auravita.com.

Hope this helps and good luck. David

What did you think of Derby blades?
 
PortsmouthDavid said:
Christoph -

Since you find yourself in the same boat, you might consider trying the line-up I outlined above. The problem for us tough beard / sensitive skin gents is that we need sharp products to deal with the tought beard, but those same items can rough up our skin. So it's a delicate balancing act. That's why I'm so pleased with the gentle razor / sharp blade combination. And of course, choosing excellent shaving soaps / creams is a big leg-up as well. Anyway, I pass it along "FWIW." You can pick up a Gillette Aristocrat on e-bay or here: http://countrycc.com/gillette_safety_razors_reconditioned.html and the Swedish Gillette blades are available at www.auravita.com.

Hope this helps and good luck. David

David,

Your choices sound simliar to mine, although I don't classify myself as having a super tough beard. However, I do have sensitive skin it seems. I have tried many, many shaving creams and have only found a handful that don't irritate my skin. I like your description of "gentle razor / sharp blade combination." I too have tried about all the blades and have settled on the Swedish Gillettes and the Feathers being my two favorites, with the Swedes probably being #1, when used in my Merkur Classic or 1904; the perfect "gentle razor / sharp blade combination," in my opinion. I also have a Gillette Aristocrat, which I have tried with the Swedes and Feathers, but for me it doesn't come near the shave quality I've received with my Merkurs.

I primarily use creams instead of soaps. I like D.R. Harris Lavender and Almond creams but have not yet tried the Arlington, however it is probably my next "buy." My favorite cream is Nancy Boy. I have found nothing that comes close to the quality of the lather and the resulting shave. But, like you, my gripe is with the "sort of in-your-face gay marketing aspect . . . i.e., the "Nancy Boy" name, the blog on the web-site with its gay politics, the "tested on boyfriends not animals" statement, etc." But they do make a great shave cream. My favorite soap thus far is Tabac.

Just wanted to throw in my two cents worth and say that I am hopefully settling in a little bit myself after my first year of returning to DE shaving in more than 20 years!
 
P

PortsmouthDavid

TheChefs said:
What did you think of Derby blades?

I have tried the Derbys, and for myself I would not move them to the front of the pack. I would classify them as quite similar to the Israeli blades . . . nice mild blade. But not the sharpest. Also, for me the blades didn't seem to be as consistent as the Israelis -- in a 5 pack I thought some were OK and a couple were really dull.

Anyway, on balance, I'd pick the Swedes. An excellent all-rounder for my money.

David
 
P

PortsmouthDavid

PottyDoctor said:
David,

My favorite soap thus far is Tabac.
QUOTE]

I have been wanting to try Tabac, but the descriptions of the scent were a bit off-putting (some users seem to describe it as a very strong pine smell which didn't much appeal to me as a concept).

But almost everyone agrees it makes a great lather. What specifically do you enjoy about Tabac?

David
 
Tabac smells nothing like pine. It is a leathery/musky scent. The soap is divine - mounds of glistening, unctuous lather. It is quite strongly scented, however, so if you don't like the scent you will hate the soap.
 
Scotto said:
Tabac smells nothing like pine. It is a leathery/musky scent. The soap is divine - mounds of glistening, unctuous lather. It is quite strongly scented, however, so if you don't like the scent you will hate the soap.

David,

Scotto has the Tabac description nailed as far as I'm concerned. The scent is not at all an off-putting scent, however I would not describe it as one of my favorites either. But for the lather...it's rich, it's creamy, it's luxurious, it's slick, it doesn't dry out and I get no irritation with it! What more is there? This is one of those soaps that the high performance lather offsets a lackluster scent. You really owe it to yourself to give Tabac a try.
 
Top Bottom