Agreed. I have the SMN Tabacco Toscano, and due to the alcohol I can't compare straight out of the bottle, but on my skin, to my nose, they're indiscernible. The splash does have good staying power (almost 6 hours for me), the original SMN TT does last longer as per it's design/purpose. That said, folks interested in having the scent of SMN Tabacco Toscano, can essentially have it for a fraction of the cost with SMdF.Splash smells dead on to a sample of SMN Tabacco Toscano I ordered. Lasts well on me too, I used a lot but got 5-6 hours or lightly wafting. Standard RR splash blend, nice stuff!