I've never tried Burt's Bees or St. John's however, the Dominica line is great. I swear by it and use it all of the time. One note however, I have yet to try them all out. I have only used the regular double distilled bay rum. I believe that classicshaving carries and you can also get it direct from the importers at www.calantilles.com. I'm lucky, our local health food store carries it so check around somewhere next to you might have it.