Two Kings*Soap commander love is the most realistic single note rose soap I’ve smelled.
saponificio varesino tundra artica has a strong rose middle note, but it’s also quite woody.
Martin di candre rose is my least favorite mdc scent. I must have gotten a bad batch. Smelled more like musky hairspray.
tobs rose was good iirc.
noble otter 2 Kong’s does have a floral rosy note. Similar to b&m lyssa.
lol