What's new

Rooney: 1/1 vs. 3/1 & Best Badger vs. Silvertip

I'm a face latherer who uses soaps & shaves only his neck. My current brush is a pure badger Vulfix 850, which has a low density and lacks a backbone, or at least that's what I suspect, other than a VDH, it's the only brush I've used.

Rooney brushes seem to be highly regarded and the prices reasonable, so I've been looking (lusting?) at them. After reading this site, it would seem like Best Badger will suit me just fine, in fact, it may even be preferable. It also seems that a stiff backboned brush, with a lower loft, smaller knot diameter would match well with my use of soaps, face lathering, & relatively small shaving area. Conclusion: Rooney 1/1 (48 mm loft version) in best badger would fit me best.

My concerns: the Rooney 3/1 looks beautiful (the 1/1 looks very nice, don't get me wrong) and I wonder if the 1/1's handle is too small (my fingers are on the stubbier side, so I doubt that it is). The disadvantage to the 3/1 is that the loft, at 55 mm, seems higher than the ideal, unless I were to purchase it at Vintage Blades, but then I would have to choose between pure badger & super silvertip. I'd probably go with the latter. On that note, I hear a lot of talk about Rooney's silvertips, but not a lot about their best badger. Is there a reason why? Do I assume correctly that their best badger brushes are great brushes?

All in all, my gut & head says, go with the Rooney 1/1 in best badger. Am I thinking straight?
 
While I much prefer the look of the Rooney 1/ handles and I own and use a 1/2 a lot will depend on how you tend to hold the brush. If you sit the handle in your palm, or hold it between fingers or, or, or..... That is really a question that only you can answer.
Your thinking about the knot makes sense to me- a dense, scrubby brush should be perfect for your needs.
Good luck.
 
I tend to hold the brush at the butt end in my fingertips, which would lead me to think that the small size shouldn't be an issue, no?
 
In that case, the handle of the 1/1 shouldn't pose any problems at all. Good luck with your hunt.
 
I have a 1/1 (in super) and it is a favorite. To tell the truth, I probably would have been just as happy with a less expensive hair (best?). When I bought, I think I was over-focused on softness and I was still thinking more $ = better brush. I have a Boar brush that is certainly a bit "rougher" than the Rooney and I like it about as much.

The overall size, the size of the knot (diameter and loft) and the size/shape of the handle are about perfect for me. The boar I also like is nearly identical in size.
 
I had a Rooney 1/2 in Best and a Rooney 1/1 in Super. While I like the smaller handle of the 1/1, I actually liked the Best hair more.

What I really like though is Simpsons Best. And it is surprisingly affordable. The Duke 1 runs about the same price as a Rooney 1/1 Super.
 
Top Bottom